Legacy Forum of Lies 2 - The Psychopathic King, Possessor, and Alchemist win

[Tanaka]

I know for a fact they are good

[Henryk]

mhm

[Tanaka]

A neutral killer can’t be killed at night so I wouldn’t save an NK and unless the NK attacked an unseen/cultie and I’ve been on one for two days (lol) then uh lol

[Henryk]

… what stops them from being starting scum in a multiball game, out of curiosity

[Henryk]

i agree that they are to be trusted ftr

[Henryk]

just. we were just talking about how mech isn’t so reliable

[Tanaka]

Nothing to be fair but I have the bias of “I saved them” so I’m liable to just want to trust them

[Henryk]

yeah ok valid

[Daan]

@BlackKalev

Quite the opposite, it’s elementary, my dear Watson.

It all can be explained by Sam being Hunter. That would explain both immunity and how Osaa was attacked. It’s also basic logic, that it’s the most likely answer we will hear from him today. Whether it is true or not will still be in question.

@BlackKalev

Polymorph is confirmable. Do we want to try it? Probably not, but option exists.

@BlackKalev

Web is also possibly confirmable. And can be done today.

@BlackKalev

MM is not immune

@BlackKalev

Checking through web / polymorph is not bad idea. I’m not sure I want to give it one more night alive, so web might be better despite being a “probability check”.

@BlackKalev

It is and it isn’t both.

If we coordinate it as to who uses the ability, it’s not. However, there is very few abilities which protect from other day abilities, as opposed to blocking a single target using them.

Most abilities are butler-like where you block a day action of single specified person. Not protect someone from actions.

@BlackKalev

I was thinking abilities like gambler’s fake bleed can be used to confirm web.
This would require us to setup web on someone, ping everyone to use instantly-confirmable on webbed person and wait for results.

@BlackKalev

And I’m saying that more information is better. What we do with it is up to us afterwards.

Why is any of this necessary?

[Tanaka]

For them to be unseen/cult they’d have to have been attacked by the NK or the other faction, but then I’d have to ask where the other factions kill went

Unless you’re saying unseen/cult killed anabelle and then unseen/cult (whoever osaa isn’t with) attacked osaa idk

[Henryk]

yeah there’s been 1 kill each night i don’t think this would be a concern in that world

[Tanaka]

Confusing one that, I think occams razor says osaa is just good

[Henryk]

me too tho

[Daan]

Confirming mechanics gets us nowhere when there is an evil version of each role.

[Tanaka]

@Henryk

yeah there’s been 1 kill each night i don’t think this would be a concern in that world

Well technically there were two last night.

[Henryk]

OH

[Henryk]

okay i get what you mean now

[Henryk]

where did the 2nd n1 kill go

[Daan]

Is Caligura the only other neutral in this game?

[Henryk]

me too
Osaa is socially good too tho