I’m not going after them, he can scumread me or whoever all they want. And they can dislike whoever’s openers, I just want specifics so that people aren’t getting away with fake or unsubstantiated reads.
Ok, but, like, unsubstantiated reads are the majority stakeholder here at Ash’s Reads.
1 Like
Gut is different from an unsubstantiated reads. Gut tells you something is off, you just don’t know what. Unsubstantiated reads are fake, and that can be fine. Could be used to feign confidence in something, could be used to generate discussion. If it was unsubstantiated though I still want to know.
all of it
Why does this seem scummy to you?
It’s bad reasoning to try and discredit earlygame votes and it doesn’t seem like a reaction town would have
I acknowledge the possibility that they are genuinely unfamiliar with RVS but it’s weird that they go from that to saying it’s not useful to vote SoD at all, rather than something like “don’t really get it but okay” which would be much more towny imo
Extremely solid reasoning, I was about to follow up questioning you about how you felt about their unfamiliarity and that’s now been covered. What did you notice with your other scumreads?
Oh, this is Olympic scumreading grading.
I see, I see, I see.
1 Like
What are your current thoughts on the game? I don’t feel like I’ve heard much from you.
I mean, I don’t like you, and I don’t like Prisma, and I don’t like how you seem to be defending Prisma by attacking Panda’s scumread of them.
Ah yes. Attacking Panda’s scumread by applauding its reasoning.
Let’s start being honest with ourselves.
Do you have thoughts on any other players in the game?
Chomps is almost certainly town.
Goose is wrong because hitting all the top posters in this game with the jail is antithetical to my SBPCBWWE shrine, but their posting seems townleany.
Pandora’s also a townlean off vibes.
What’re your reads?
Pandora went out of their way to explain their RVS vote choice (which afaik is something that comes from mafia more often than town) and I didn’t really vibe with their fluffposting (weakest of my scumreads as of yet)
As for you, I felt like your opening (specifically #87) was trying too hard to seem like solving considering how few actual reads you mentioned
2 Likes
Not sure how clear it is based on my justifications (I think it’s pretty obvious) but my reads are 99% vibes rn, I just like to act like I’m confident in them to fuck with scum in the off chance i’m actually right
3 Likes
I really like red panda’s analysis of the game so far, so I townread them. I appreciate their willingness to communicate their thoughts instead of being combative to my questions. I also think them acknowledging that their reads aren’t based on much but choosing to push them anyway for content reads as a town player.
Red panda had a convincing case on Prisma, which you can see if you scroll up, so I’m inclined to scumread Prisma. I especially liked Panda’s follow up as to why their unfamiliarity with RVS doesn’t excuse them either.
Typically I find people whose reads seem to be thread consensus to be wolfy. Right now, you seem to be that person, especially with the way that you claimed I was attacking Panda instead of simply asking for more content. That says to me you aren’t looking deeply into my posts, which would imply you aren’t looking deeply into others posts either, and yet you seem to have a lot of reads which is very strange to me.
My mind has extreme receny bias, so these are the few I feel any sort of confidence on. I do remember getting good vibes from goose but they also haven’t posted for a spell. I haven’t gotten much of a ping either way for the rest of the playerlist. Magnus keeps popping up in my mind but I can’t figure out why.
1 Like
Could you explain any of these reads more?
Vibes, OMGUS, vibes.