MHA FM Game Thread - GAME OVER - VILLAIN TEAM WINS

[Isolde]

Arctic is definitely town and probably Kiiruma as well.

[Squirrel2412]

why not?

if I understood it correctly, your case is based off of misty being inconsistent and backtracking

(if not, correct me)

[Cape90]

@Mistyx

but im probably biased because i think his case on me is made up

“made up”

All cases are made up what do you mean. I read through your ISO and I was thoroughly unimpressed outside of the 4 posts that I pulled up and called you wolfy for

[Isolde]

@Cape90

@Mistyx

your case sucked because you pulled four posts out of context from my iso and said they made me a lock wolf

Even though I may have acted like it, I don’t think you are lock wolf off 4 posts lmao.

I mean TBF Kiiruma and Brad thought I was. (Or at least Kiiruma) so what makes you different then them?

[Isolde]

If your saying your a better read you shouldn’t have voted me or sus’ed Kiiruma

[Isolde]

Reader*

[Prophylaxis]

@Squirrel2412

for whatever reason I see this as towny

it’s probably not actually but I like it anyways

i feel like this is the third time someone has said this about me and idk how i feel about it

[Cape90]

@Squirrel2412

why not?

if I understood it correctly, your case is based off of misty being inconsistent and backtracking

That’s like… half of the case on them and doesn’t even account for the other half. I wouldn’t find being inconsistent and backtracking scummy on their own.

@Isolde

I mean TBF Kiiruma and Brad thought I was. (Or at least Kiiruma) so what makes you different then them?

It seems like common sense to me fam. Nobody is “lock wolf” day 1.

[Cape90]

My current POE is Mistyx/Gorta/Propylaxis/Squirrel

[Cape90]

Brad is leagues townier this game then the hydra game we just played. Sorry, can’t wolfread that slot

[Squirrel2412]

cape iso

@Cape90

I am looking at all this and I would say this is not a slot I would end up pushing today. I think pushing strong players versus strong mafia players is inherently anti-town and ruins the gamestate of the game anyway. Now that sounds like something mafia would want doesn’t it

do you actually think arctic is strong/towny or are you just basing this comment off of what other ppl are saying?

@Cape90

• I think this is a towny thought, it seems like a bold assumption to me.
• Not sure how messed up this thing is but, I think the “well now i’m curious” was a towny thing to say. On top of that I don’t think wolves would be as so blunt as to say “also you hit the nail on the head there”.
• Arctic’s sassiness here gave a town vibe okay?

these reads seem a bit forced, but I’m willing to give a pass since I’m pretty sure I see everything as forced or fake

going back and elaborating is a good look, though

@Cape90

Oh well okay then, I hope this works out.

Isolde has literally talked the most in this thread

this attempt to defend isolde is a bit… halfhearted? fake it seems like cape is trying to make posts to argue against yeeting isolde but doesn’t actually care if isolde gets yeeted

the reasoning is very weak and might be TMI (if so, I think it spews kii + seth town)

@Cape90

I think now the question is “does wolf have this power” I mean for real. I have literally never seen wolf with this sort of role so

/vote Kiiruma @Eraserhead

@Cape90

Oh I thought it was the other way around.

@Isolde

@catbae

not really sure why kiiruma is so gung ho on Isolde but would like to amend my earlier read of “probably town” to very, very town.

Idk, but I think there is a wolf in Kiiruma and Brad.

That explains this then.

/vote Isolde @Eraserhead

I’m inclined to think this is a better look for cape (or at least implies not w/w with kii or isolde), since I don’t really think he would forget his partners’ abilities.

otoh, could just be a case of kii/isolde t/t and wolf not caring

@Cape90

@catbae

Discussion of the theoretical value of such analysis isn’t of interest to me, I don’t doubt your belief in it and I sharply disagree, but that is not the point I am trying to make. My point was you seemed to be wanting to over-focused on arguing about a non-aligned read based on incredibly slight reasoning, one that ultimately boils down to scum would/wouldn’t act this way together in early game. It boils down to personal interpretation and so is easy to argue for either way. The decision to argue about that pinged me because it felt like arguing for the sake of arguing rather than having any legitimate interest in arctic’s perspective, either for determining his own alignment or for reconsidering the non-alignment read between wzza and lol.

This seems like a lot of thought was put into especially the second post and this snippet.
“…it felt like arguing for the sake of arguing rather than having any legitimate interest in arctic’s perspective, either for determining his own alignment or for reconsidering the non-alignment read between wzza and lol.”

which given this, do you think if Prophylaxis is wolf, does that make wazza and lol town?

I really don’t get why catbae has been catching heat for some of their posting that seems reasonable like not wanting to gladiate someone a few hours into day 1. I personally feel like it’s a good day 2 type of play but not necessarily late game.

I disagree with this read; putting a lot of thought into a post that’s mostly defensive/explanatory isn’t necessarily towny - most scum would put thought into defending themselves

---

[already commented on the misty case]

---

@Cape90

If we can actually vote sleep here, it might not be a bad play, but aren’t we forced to vote?

this post doesn’t really commit to anything
I dislike it

@Cape90

@Isolde

He’s doing this to try and look good after my Yeet.

How would he look good after your yeet unless you are mafia?

maybe tmi

@Cape90

Arctic maybe I am too tired to understand what you are doing, but given this message why are you voting sleep? Do you not believe a word you are saying?

this is oddly aggressive

tl;dr: cape maybe scum, fine with flipping tomorrow unless something else happens

[Wazza]

why is it everytime I enter the thread someone is talking about Cape
I’m starting to think he’s town just because he’s constantly being discussed

[Squirrel2412]

it means I’m naive

or something idk maybe you just exude towniness

[Squirrel2412]

@Cape90

That’s like… half of the case on them and doesn’t even account for the other half. I wouldn’t find being inconsistent and backtracking scummy on their own .

…so what’s the other half?

[Arctic]

@BradLand

Don’t need one, if you’re a misfire then it isn’t on me.
If you’re a wolf and you don’t get yeeted, it isn’t on me either.

i like to call this phenomenon fol syndrome

[Host_Account_2]

The only players eligible to be voted are Isolde and Kiiruma.

Official VC

Voted	Voter	Votes
Isolde	BradLand, Kiiruma, Isolde	3/7
Kiiruma		0/7
Sleep	Mistyx, lol, Arctic, Squirrel, cape	5/7
Not Voting	Gorta, Prophylaxis, YouButWorse, catbae, Wazza	5

Pinging hosts for new votes and mistakes is highly appreciated ^^

[Arctic]

@Squirrel2412

Does your read change if I told you mistyx is also hedgey as town?

why do you keep saying this
didn’t misty confirm you were getting confused with someone else

[Arctic]

@Squirrel2412

@Cape90

@Isolde

He’s doing this to try and look good after my Yeet.

How would he look good after your yeet unless you are mafia?

maybe tmi

i don’t understand this? feels like a bit of a reach to shade here. same with the comment about being aggressive

im not a huge fan of squirrel’s cape iso, it kinda feels like they had an agenda to shade cape before they started making the post…

and the one reason he’s given to townread cape is due to a preflip?..

@Squirrel2412

I’m inclined to think this is a better look for cape (or at least implies not w/w with kii or isolde), since I don’t really think he would forget his partners’ abilities.

otoh, could just be a case of kii/isolde t/t and wolf not caring

idgi

@Squirrel2412 if you could expand upon this maybe that would help

[Arctic]

@Wazza

Brad null, Arctic town, you town, Kii null, Mist null, catbae null

going sleep and going to miss over a thousand posts and then never read them, goodnight

@Wazza have any of your reads changed since here? kinda want to see a bit more from you.

[Arctic]

as it stands tomorrow i would probably kill in mistyx/catbae/lol

want to see more from gorta/YBW probably but these are next on the shitlist