MHA FM Game Thread - GAME OVER - VILLAIN TEAM WINS

[Prophylaxis]

spoiler alert: i think that seth last game played a lot more conventionally that he is in this game

this game he’s kind of like a bull in a china shop i feel

[Prophylaxis]

ok im actually going to bed

i did more than i thought i was going to in the past hour

[Squirrel2412]

@Cape90

Oh well okay then, I hope this works out.

Isolde has literally talked the most in this thread

@Squirrel2412

this attempt to defend isolde is a bit… halfhearted? fake it seems like cape is trying to make posts to argue against yeeting isolde but doesn’t actually care if isolde gets yeeted

the reasoning is very weak and might be TMI (if so, I think it spews kii + seth town)

@Cape90

At the time I thought it could have been someone else that gladiated, when I should have just read the thread better. It was more of an observation I made based on the 2 options presented for the gladiator and truth be told, I hadn’t actually read Isolde really all that closely, think they are town with their back and forth with Brad.

huh.
so back then you thought isolde was null, but a worse option that kii?

just tryna parse your reasoning here

@Cape90

This seems like a lot of thought was put into especially the second post and this snippet.
“…it felt like arguing for the sake of arguing rather than having any legitimate interest in arctic’s perspective, either for determining his own alignment or for reconsidering the non-alignment read between wzza and lol.”

which given this, do you think if Prophylaxis is wolf, does that make wazza and lol town?

I really don’t get why catbae has been catching heat for some of their posting that seems reasonable like not wanting to gladiate someone a few hours into day 1. I personally feel like it’s a good day 2 type of play but not necessarily late game.

@Squirrel2412

I disagree with this read; putting a lot of thought into a post that’s mostly defensive/explanatory isn’t necessarily towny - most scum would put thought into defending themselves

@Cape90

Okay. For me it just didn’t seem like the 2 posts were really thoughts and pushes that I could see mafia making/posting. I even tested catbae to see if they held consistent logic in their not liking to make associative reads early, I have played with catbae before so I wanted to see if their town logic was in tact. It was which is a good look.

that’s fair. my main concern with those posts was more about that they could be made by scum trying to blend in rather than scum pushing town.

out of curiosity, how many games have you played with catbae?

I’ve played 0 so don’t worry you’ll still beat me

@Squirrel2412

@Cape90

If we can actually vote sleep here, it might not be a bad play, but aren’t we forced to vote?

this post doesn’t really commit to anything
I dislike it

@Cape90

Okay lemme explain. So on my homesite mafia.gg, there is a similar role to this whole gladiator thing, it’s called pollster. 1. they are always town (which is why I commented that I have only seen a town version of this role). 2. In that role, we are forced to kill one of them or the other, and CANNOT sleep. I am thankful it doesn’t seem that way here since we like, actually could sleep in this scenario.

sure
but that post didn’t really seem like you had an opinion about whether we should sleep

“might not be a bad play” is very noncommital and makes it easy for a wolf to pivot to either stance

[Gorta]

@Prophylaxis

spoiler alert: i think that seth last game played a lot more conventionally that he is in this game

this game he’s kind of like a bull in a china shop i feel

that’s what other people were saying

[Squirrel2412]

hmm

I could maybe see that
I’ll look into it later

[Gorta]

I remember people were starting to think Seth was a wolf for making too much sense

[Host_Account_2]

The only players eligible to be voted are Isolde and Kiiruma.

Official VC

Voted	Voter	Votes
Isolde	BradLand, Kiiruma, Isolde	3/7
Kiiruma		0/7
Sleep	lol, Arctic, Squirrel, cape	4/7
Not Voting	Gorta, Prophylaxis, YouButWorse, catbae, Wazza, Mistyx	6

Pinging hosts for new votes and mistakes is highly appreciated ^^

[Wazza]

@Mistyx

prob spewed v if kiiruma wolf but idt thats worth considering at this point

Can you explain?
Further can you explain why you’d make a point like this and then say this:

@Mistyx

isolde squirrel kiiruma

brad arctic prophylaxis

lol catbae cape

ybw gorta wazza

[Wazza]

@Arctic

this one surprises me
elaborate?

His lack of care towards my pressure about his slot due to him coming in and out just gives me town vibes like he really doesn’t care if he’s townread or scumread, he just feels relaxed in the thread even before the gladiator

[Wazza]

@Isolde

Cape/Cat/YBW throw them as wolves.

Can you explain?

Moreso on the Cat one, I’ll read up on Cape later and I honestly say I can read YBW at least 60% of the time so I’ll check out his ISO later as well

@Prophylaxis

i just find it incredibly odd that she moved me to null from town in her ~updated readlist~ and i want to see an explanation of that from her

Yeah I can explain
Your read on me is literally just nothing, you called me scum for practically nothing and now you’re placing me as your top scum candidate when all you did was say I was jumpy? No clue what you even meant by that but you never went into depth on it and what you did was that you read me without the intention to townread me to begin with

[Gorta]

lol is really reminding me of lol from the last game if we are being honest and if that’s the case then I want to say lol is town

[Gorta]

as for cat I don’t quite know right now, but upon the initial skimming I think cat is leaning town for me

[Gorta]

I’ll put my vote in the morning, but I’m probably going to vote sleep. I think lol has said that Seth is town and lol was also right last game, so I’m kind of trusting that. I’m also seeing that people have said that Seth was making sense last game and Seth isn’t here, so it’s possible I’m paranoid. I know I’m very untrusting of many people, so I’ll compare the two games when I’m not tired

[Gorta]

in the mean time I’m going to bed, but @lol could you provide reasoning for your read on Seth?

[Arctic]

@Gorta

@Isolde

Cape is probably wolf and if we don’t let me die, we wasted Kiiruma’s ability and potentially others.

ok, but if you think you are both town you don’t have to let mafia use said ability to kill a towny player

???

[Arctic]

@Gorta

the only chance Kii uses gladiate as scum is if y’all are partners

what

[Arctic]

@Mistyx

also doesnt really line up with him thinking seth was wolfy earlier?

i don’t understand this
he is calling seth wolfy in the posts

[Gorta]

I’m currently winding down reading a book, but basically if Kii is town and we kill Seth to “not waste the ability” then we are letting the wolves use this to kill a towny in worlds seth is also town

[Gorta]

I’ve explained this as well, it’s in my posts

[Arctic]

okay i will finish catching up later

still feel good about my poe but some of gorta’s worldbuilding around the dome is probably villagery