arctic was worried that town would have a bunch of slankers and we would end up misyeeting within them
my point was that having mentors would hopefully encourage people who normally slank as town to post more
the thing about top posters was more a coincidence - the main reason I thought there was a wolf there is that each of you had at least one scumread among the other 3 (except arctic, I think?) and that it was really unlikely that all 4 of you are that bad at reading each other
you just happened to be the top 4 posters which made describing you as a group really easy
cop-out excuse, no offence but I’ll take it as I’ve said the same thing multiple times.
I saw you mentioned something to do with Flygon as you voted Eliza so fair points for that one.
Either way this doesn’t feel like a mostly justified reason on why you voted Eliza, just the fact you had no other reads and wanted to buy yourself time? In this case, why wouldn’t you no-execute? (I am aware how bad No-Exe truly is but based on what you said there’s no argument against why you wouldn’t vote for it)
Vulgard I don’t have much on, if you want my thoughts I’m not a fan about not being really pinged by too much on his posts, but that might just be a good thing, either way I’ll read into him later when I get the chance after class.
I’ve got over 4 years and look at me, still useless as ever lmao
More or less, but I place more emphasis on it because you are a good player and can fake reads well. You even say so yourself in later posts.
Why is that towny? Maybe he’s unable to fabricate other content?
Not sure why you’re latching onto the point about saving Flygon when I’ve explained more. It’s not just that, it’s the lack of interest in EoD, which is the more important part.
This is honestly the towniest post you’ve written today, though. But it’s also the type of post I misread.
I explained at the beginning of #936.
I like Wazza’s entry reads, she can be town. They could’ve been made up before she entered the game (and I think she admitted as much) but I still like them.
Why is me not using meta to read you a problem? You said it yourself, you are not polarized.
So you’re voting me and want to yeet me because I’m a good player? And that’s it?
In the last game we played together, you had actual reads. They were wrong at first, but almost everybody’s were, and they were still reads. You also had suspicions on players previously townread and overlooked.
You aren’t doing any of that here. You basically aren’t playing the game.
I can’t explain it very well, but they have seemed genuine all game. Their process looks transparent and they’ve had towny-looking approaches to several players. I was going to ISO them, but I’ve had no time to do that, unfortunately; if I’m able, I will do that and give you a better answer.
Talk to me about it?
This reaction honestly looks exaggerated. What confused you there?
Do YOU have reads on Us Four Players? Or are you going to write us off as “one wolf in there” and call it a day? Because that isn’t helpful at all. I’ve been trying to solve these players all day, you’ve done nothing of the sort and just given a broad take on them. How is that conducive to accomplishing anything today?
I’ve been terribly busy today, which is why I haven’t been posting, but I still want to kill Arctic and I’m keeping my vote. I just explained the issues I have with his more recent posting. His post about Flygon not being PR is the towniest of them all, but I could see that posted by a wolf. Marshal, for example, has done something similar before as mafia (ironically, about Arctic).
If I’m able to attend EoD, I might change my mind, but right now I don’t have a better candidate. I’ve wanted to kill Squirrel as well, but I’m not satisfied with the strength of my read on him. He could be mafia, I’m not saying he isn’t, I just don’t really have a case still. I’d rather go where my confidence is higher.
I still dislike the fact NP is just tunneling one player and refusing to give reads on others. His take on Arctic was a nothingburger - he used a lot of words to say “he doesn’t understand Arctic.” Then Arctic gave a townread on him that I didn’t like, because it seemed like he was giving too much credit to NP. Probably the most likely partner if I’m right about Arctic, keep that in mind if I’m nightkilled.
Ashlyn’s random emotional reaction to one of my posts looks weirdly exaggerated. I want her to explain what that was even about.
I think Magnus is town, but I could see him being a wolf and fooling me. Not going to go there today, but yeah.
Wazza should probably just be cleared if Arctic flips wolf because I don’t see her bussing right away. Sure, she could have a pregame wolfread on him, but I don’t think she would drop it as a replacement. I guess she had time to do some strategizing if she’s a wolf, but I still don’t think that’s the approach. Wolves would need to be in a really bad spot for that approach to be necessary. Judging by how EOD1 went, they are likely not in a bad spot.
Wolves not being in a bad spot (in all likelihood) is the main reason I’m conflicted on Squirrel.
If you bothered to read my posts you would notice I said that EoD votes ain’t gonna do a whole lot.
If you actually look why I voted and look at my thought process throughout it you will notice that it isn’t as wolfy as you think it is (or at least I’d hope so)
As I already said before, I was trying to search for an alternative wagon but the only one I could get was Eliza and I already found some of their posts wolfy.
I didn’t want Shending anymore.
I definitely didn’t want Kanave voted.
I obviously didn’t wanna die.
So my only option was to push for someone else and I was trying to push for Arctic but no one was caring to give a shit to go there.
Read the context please, don’t just look at the votes themselves, as I explained above.
Now however, I could be wrong on Ashlyn.
I narrowed it where I’m very confident Arctic and Penguin are both wolves.
But I’m not entirely sure who their final partner is but I was thinking it to be either Squirrel or Ashlyn.
Im thinking arctic and flygon might be disaligned. V/w This might be hella dumb but thinking about that eod flygon wolf works but could an arctic wolf who was aperhetic until wagons started getting chaotic and so jumped on eliza bc easy mislynch make sense?
