Hmm ok, I can see what you are saying and I believe Era said something similar.
Which thoughts did you feel was controversial? the tr on you?
I do agree with “hardly holding on” since it’s something that can easily come from both alignments.
What do you make of Era’s read on you?
I see you explained it but do you think of the read itself from Era?
VOTE: Estelle
I am breaking my silence on this after all.
Mostly as Juliette has done exactly what I was hoping someone to do.
Estelle is most certainly some sort of saboteur as they have so far reverberated off others reads and attempted to undermine the growing townread on myself while also piggy backing off Drek’ar’s suspicion of Luna.
(Initial posts up to Number 75 are effectively nothing.
Number 86 Is perhaps the worst post as they are effectively trying to reverberate Drek’ar as a boosting point to discredit townreads on me (a growing trend) while also not being the primary voice for it. I did agree at the time that Luna’s read on me was premature however someone protecting you often leads to town reading them which is why I ignored that point of suspicion on Luna.
Number 98 is actually when my suspicions arose because the defense was not to state on the more correct things mentioned, or other suspicions, but specifically to target the one mistake Era made in their reading of the post. (Which wasn’t the majority of the read as far as I understood.)
I do not believe this is a slam-dunk of a case but perhaps the most overt and reasonable suspicion so far.
More the reads on you (no one had stated read and you’d only been fluffy to that point) and Drek’ar (who had been sussed and I was the only one who had townread them.)
I believe multiple people had townread me already by that point, I would hardly claim it contreversial.
Disregarding the rest of the post, I believe this is towny and I am locking Atlas as town from this. This is an inherently towny mindset that mafia members usually don’t think to fake. I think you should be able to tell what I mean here without me explaining it…
Hahaha, I may have overlooked a bit. You are the calm leader we need.
I agree with overall Era’s analysis/questioning was good and I had similar thoughts on Era’s interactions with Estelle afterward with the townie self-awareness.
VOTE: Estelle
By that last statement, do you feel like Luna is very scummy by the way you mentioned “how they would know how it feels like”?
How much stock do you really put in early townreads as a reason for someone to be scum? I know you discussed you won’t elaborate on some of your other reads, but what do you think of X giving out the 3 town reads as their first post then?
that’s fair I suppose.
It’s not amazing but given the time in the thread it was not a bad thought.
Don’t worry Atlas, I will hopefully grow up to be the mature striker in our league very soon!
`
See, this is interesting, because now it feels like if Estella was agreeing with Drekar on how Luna’s tr felt “TMI’ish” for the emptiness behind it, it’s even more weird how Estella responded to Luna’s response on how they tr you. They stated how it doesn’t matter why the tr happen but the fact that it happened early based on “pressure.”
It seems that Estella is changing the goal posts of the initial reason to scum read Luna and doesn’t quite sit right with me.
If I am reading this incorrectly lmk, but that’s my thought on it.
Atlas, I was in lab and class for the majority of time that this thread was opened. During that time I was dividng my efforts on reading the thread and focusing on in class. I did not have time to formulate a full response to everything Era said - something that you yourself should know, as you yourself ackowelged the fact that I was in class.
I am done with lab and can start focusing on the thread and replying to stuff.
And also, I don’t really get that sense and felt like Dre’kar was being a bit overreactive in respect to their read on you and Luna, but they had stated that themselves as well with some of their reads which didn’t sit right.
You also stated that you’d become engrossed in the thread over your irl requirements.
But I am open to being proven wrong. My hypothetical is only as strong as that data that supports it.
So go on. Be the towniest striker you can be. Prove me wrong. Show me that you believe strongly enough in the integrity of the league structure that I find my previous analysis wanting. Then we can go on to crush saboteurs together.
Do you think Drek’ar is suspicious then?
Luna has given me the “I am here so I don’t get fined vibes” which on surface level seems like one who is not as stressed or worried about how they appear in thread which is rand town.
`
Lore nerd for a beta game.
Yes. Idk if I explicitly stated, but I’d put around null-scum.
“tonally” they seem ok, so I am waiting to see how it develops. Hence null-scum
Also @Atlas_OS, I know you mentioned you had revealed your read partially bc I had also touched up on it, but is there a reason you revealed as soon as you did, considering you wanted to wait to see how it develops further in thread?