Not really as it’s never gonna be granted really. Unless it was to a Miller who always shows as W. But even then that’s confirmation of their claim.
Suffering
(for the record, my job is me going to stores and doing inventory)
And you know that how?
I am W a statistically higher amount than average in other communities. Here I feel like I’m relatively normal between town and W games
It’s the most overpowered wish one could make.
Like public role reveal is weaker and even that is inssnely OP.
I mean
There is something to be said about the boldness of wishing for it
Since there’s always a chance for it to be granted
A really low chance, but a chance nonetheless
And it also makes you a target as well. Like with Mayor and IC.
imo it is like 1% more towny than rand because of that
Oh yeah, it’s bold. But I refuse to townread for it. Since even if Eliza is W who gets it granted Eliza can be like “That helps me confirm as Miller. A wolf would never do that” and town would eat that up.
I’d say maybe 5-10% more towny actually.
Also
Someone suspected Guava for not wanting Eliza killed d1
That is almost certainly NAI frankly getting d1’d sucks, it sucks even more when it happens multiple times in a row
1 Like
No they wouldn’t because it would confirm her as wolf.
Nah, 5-10% feels a bit excessive
I’d go 3% at the highest
1 Like
I absolutely agree with not D1ing Eliza. But doesn’t mean I’m gonna give free reads out too.
Fair enough.
ftr
town miller eliza wouldnt wish that before claiming miller lol
Eliza as whole is a firm null for me
I also agree with not D1ing Eliza.
No.
A Miller could show up as red while being green. Depends on how it’s worded. So it’s a safe excuse for Eliza. And same vice versa with a Godfather or Tailor.