Pathologic Invitational - TOWN VICTORY!!

[Whysper]

@Vulgard

Arctic (sorry Whysper but i think you’re wrong)

Yeah, I’m thinking more and more that I probably was

[Arctic]

@Vulgard

then jar

this is actually a good point

what happened to your jar read eliza lol

[Vulgard]

consider the previous couple of posts my legacy

vote is staying on beancat

[Vulgard]

i know a legacy is pointless while the poisonous goon is alive but if they die then i should probably clarify this
good night

[beancat]

@Vulgard

townreading nokiel in p#312 for the push on her but is now pushing them

that was in contrast to arctic

my issue with nokiel is that the “pressure vote” of oh let’s get them to participate more has been the extent of their activity

[Vulgard]

@beancat

my issue with nokiel is that the “pressure vote” of oh let’s get them to participate more has been the extent of their activity

false and bad faith sorry

[Vulgard]

ok good night

[Arctic]

@beancat

Kanave feels town, from her detailed reads on nokiel/Eliza/one more i forgot which one
plus this

so do you think her eliza scumread holds merit?

[Arctic]

false and badfaithpilled

[Whysper]

Good night, Vul

[Whysper]

I considered moving my vote to Vul’s wagon just to make him stay up, but that would be mean

[May]

I’m not saying that she is a big pull on thread right now; I just that think she could push through a different execution if she wanted, because she’s currently widely townread. I guess her absence could make sense as wolf with Kanave, if she’s really not confident in herself, but I also just… generally townread her, so I don’t think it’s particularly realistic.

[beancat]

I’m not confident that they’re correct

Like this is the conclusion:

@Kanave

In the first ones she’s making a more solid case connecting the thoughts, but in her town example she just kinda goes off on random thoguhts without really wrapping them up in one solid package. I can see what you’re saying with the “thought (they) cause someone dead to rights” but personally i only had a gut feeling that it was towny and i didn’t want to confuse people by saying that post felt towny, while not liking the rest of their iso, and providing evidence that she plays differently as a wolf an towny and this fits more into the wolf slot of what i was providing?? idk my thoguhts here were just messy so i left them out, hindsight obv shouldn’t have left them out its better to just tell everyone im confused but i was conflicted

Which is very dependent on a meta that Eliza is more random as town and plays different as scum

I’m not sold on that argument, but Kanave going through Eliza’s post and coming to that conclusion seems natural from the pov they provide

[Arctic]

so what is your read on eliza

[ElizaThePsycho (Willow)]

@beancat

@Arctic

i think repeatedly showing awareness of the fact they aren’t playing and then still not playing is probably wolfy, because they are trying to keep up appearances like “oh i’m here guys dw” without actually helping to solve

This is not
Me not following up on my promises to participate is, surprise surpirse, very common
I feel bad about it regardless of my alignment and will talk about it

This is absolutely true btw

@beancat

Arctic is for some reason determined to kill me today instead ofntaking the towny approach of “here have pressure” that nokiel is taking

Not sure if this is true but honestly I find the OMGUS townie

@beancat

Definitely not the kill today
I don’t entirely agree with the read and don’t think effort clears may, but better to have them around than me

Okay this read is kinda wolfy, it’s like she’s trying to
Actually there’s no really justifiable wolf motivation
Not clearing because wolves don’t do everything with everything in mind but yeah

@beancat

@May

It’s there , sure, but it’s not presented in a way that makes it feel like Aelin is taking responsibility for it, you know? It feels like this post is intended to make the reader come to their own conclusions, so that she can flexibly explain it away later on.

Disagree on this one, but not of much value anyway since it’s differing in the way we read ppl
Them just saying “well this sus in a way idk how to explain” is relatable not that scummy to me

Wouldn’t expect this from wolf!bean ngl
Maybe on a partner but aelin flipped town so

@beancat

On the flipside Nokiel is definitely on my kill list, they’ve not done anything concretely scummy like Lemon but their general attitude feels very nonconfrontational

Their two votes yesterday and beginning of D2 were only for “pressure”

Plus there’s this readlist:

@Nokiel

Arc - Townlean, seeming very focused on keeping discussion going and getting the game solved.

Addendum: seems worse given the frustration. Seems genuine though.

Lemon - Townlean - Very open and feels unfiltered, which comes across as towny

Vul - Very focused thoughts and it does feel like they’re trying to solve. Happy with responses to questions.

Eliza - Null, not that much to go off of, the EoD brought some content, but haven’t properly analyzed.

Whysper - Well, poisoned and generally been focused and also not sheeped when the opportunity has been there.

May - Town. Very solvy and has been pushing a lot when on. The pressure to solve and be a good townie seems genuine.

Bean - Null, Waiting on more Activity

Jar - Townlean/null, seems very blunt and somewhat unfiltered…?

Kanave - Null, Lack of content, waiting for some content.

With everything being “town” for the more active ones and “null” for the lesser active ones
Like they never call out any scummy actions

Even their last vote:

@Nokiel

I still feel like it’s been gut and then no effort to continue.

They don’t actually look into whether someone is scummy, just for low-effort

Actually I like this read a lot
Not something the average person notices regarding the read list
I don’t think it’s true because new player but

Anyway yeah Idt I like a bean kill today

[beancat]

townlean from EoD1
haven’t read their D2

[ElizaThePsycho (Willow)]

I realized it was stupid and promptly abandoned it
Didn’t I post about that?

[beancat]

@ElizaThePsycho

I don’t think it’s true because new player but

wouldn’t new player make this more true
being nonconfrontational is pretty common for a newbie scum

[ElizaThePsycho (Willow)]

No just new players reads are way too often based on activity

[Arctic]

@ElizaThePsycho

@May

What if they flipped town?

i would townread arctic because ooo reads from beyond the grave oo
and find somebody else to push

@ElizaThePsycho why would you care about aelin’s reads if they were wrong on you