Pokemon Xros Wars Game Over Mafia Victory

Forum Games Completed
,
#9707

Meanwhile, me (who has hosted a game with you twice in it):

As a setup designer, I often worry whether my roles are truly good or not.

Let’s see, you were…

  • Mafia 3-Shot 2-Targeting Roleblocker in Starcraft Overhaul
  • Town Counting Multi-voter in Nightmare Woods

I recall you got Vanilla-ized N1 in Nightmare Woods after Gorta died. Was it truly not a design problem?

#9708

are the masons lovers in that setup?

#9709

Im waiting for someone to make mario kart mafia. That sounds fair

1 Like
#9710

then for extra fairness points, make it so the blueshell kills the top poster. That sounds incredibily fair and not toxic at all

2 Likes
#9711

reeeeeeee

#9712

Looks good IMO.

#9713

(aka: how to make no one talk)

1 Like
#9714

This is good for fol :froggwee:

#9715

Nope. It’s not… too bad to make them lovers, but I think it pushes the game to being much more scum sided. If I was making the masons lovers in that setup, I’d add a weak town PR to compensate, I think.

#9716

excepet after 2 blushells the thread is dead

#9717

id appreciate it
i havent balanced a full game in uh
uhm
2 years…?
something tells me this isnt a very good first host kind of game

#9718

I don’t think it was.

My play style is not conducive to FoL in general i think and so there’s a play style clash but also I think town on FoL regularly struggles to work together.

I think we won Starcraft because of that even though it should’ve been an easy catch by the end who mafia was.

2 Likes
#9719

Nooo worries. Shall I dm you on discord?

#9720

The banana peel for those who do not meet the post criteria in day phrase.

#9721

…let’s just say I don’t have enough hosting experience to ever learn this. There was one time when I was surprised at what “balance” means is when mafia won in a 2v9 setup.

So yeah: Clearly I am not an expert despite being a reviewer. (Which is why I keep dragging other reviewers with me to double-check whether the setups I review is actually good or not.)

#9722

i think what i learnt from this game is thaa

#9723

After Happy Tree Friends FM incident, that should be encouraged. :+1:

#9724

town should work together

2 Likes
#9725

We once had access to a LARGE data pool of 10-3 Mountainous (means Vanilla) games, which showed that it was about that percent scum sided after some statistical analysis.

Now, again, MS is a tiny bit it’s own ecosystem but we also looked around at other sites for 10-3 nilla and our evidence was more or less confirmed.

10-3 is a slightly scum sided setup. Scum should win more often than they lose.

1 Like
#9726

Lemme also manipulate while I am doing that :slight_smile: