fair
but the way you kept waffling back and forth about whether you townread her today felt to me like you were feeling out the thread to see if it was a viable push
No I just haven’t ISO’d her posts from today lol
If it sounds like I’m hedging it’s because my main point has been that she shouldn’t be cleared, not that she’s lockscum
I can’t deny people townreads on her, but I will not let them towncore someone I’ve seen get towncored early as a wolf before for poor reasons when I was the only one scumreading them correctly.
And I think it’s notable that I’ve been denying allowing her into the towncore territory and she has not once interacted with me in this game except to say that the one post where I complained about marshal’s PoE was disingenuous because she had put min into the PoE on the condition she was wrong about someone else, and I thought min was just upper PoE for her.
1 Like
I’ll just resolve it this way
@Marshal what’s your current read on me and why?
I asked you yesterday why I’m at the bottom of your readlist and I don’t remember ever getting a response, but lo and behold, you still scumread me for unspecified reasons, last I checked, and haven’t engaged with me.
imo vulgard scumreading/shading alana is v!spew and not distancing in the context of his arguments with jc
in his wallpost where he fights thread consensus, vulgard chooses to keep alana as a scumread (a view he’s held all day)
if alana were wolf I think vulgard would just let jc townread alana and not fight over that read
1 Like
Valid point
And Vulgard had his vote on Alana for a while too, longer than he had it on JC iirc
Idk how that factors in but just something to note
And - as I pointed out parts of - I have a green check on both Alana and Marshal. There’s no need to investigate the two of them further.
1 Like
The only one I’m unsure about here is Blade but as I said I don’t think there’s a point in investigating him further for the time being.
I’m not that confident on Squirrel being a wolf outside of JC’s reads. JC can be wrong. He totally nuked Vulgard though and mad respect for that. Maybe he’s right on Squirrel as well.
Don’t like that I’m voting Squirrel with Mistyx though, at the moment I can see her being a wolf as well.
(@JohnCarter good thing you didn’t die early in Swag because that would likely have made me sheep your read on YOLO instead of blasting him, I care way too much about your reads this game)
Which leaves the wolves inside the box of:
Hippopablompoyeetus
BS4215
Kyubey
LASERpointer
Marluxion
Millium
min
Mistyx
nightingale
nutella
Squirrel2412
Wazza
WindwardAway
Which, eh, is quite the list of people. How many wolves left? 4? I haven’t mathed this yet.
Who should I scratch from this list and why?
I only care about strong reads, not guesses.
wazza is trying to scare people from voting her by blatantly softing vengeful and i’m tempted to just kill her for it
no i feel like on a macro level she is a wolf and it’s a few micro things that make her town which is why i’m not sold on her being town
this was a good waste of time
take off kyubey because vulgard really just gave that slot no breathing room and cast it out as “should 100% be killed” for the neut claim
take min nutella and hippo have out because they’ve all been insanely villagery
2 Likes
Oh, I missed that part completely 
she only claimed the greencheck on alana tbf
the claim looks insanely fake anyway so i’m just ignoring it
claiming 1-shot just looks like a cop out following the discussion that “wait this game is just useless roles, there’s no alignment cop” and i don’t get how they have 2 checks
2 Likes
Noted.
The min one is the only one I have no idea about, the other ones I can see.
That implies the wolves are in BS/Laser/Marl/Mill/Misty/Night/Squirrel/Wazza/Wind
Still a lot to unpack.
No worries, I wasn’t very vocal about it!
I was guessing 5 wolves but now I’ve seen several people assume there are 4 wolves and I’m kinda wondering what the reasoning is on that
Ftr this is roughly where I’m at as well
Idk I can give it more thought later
Should maybe prioritize solving other slots since so many people are of the strong opinion Marshal is town but I’m still iffy on it
Nah there’s a way that works but I’m not gonna say what I think about it