Poor Approximations of Catgirls - Thread 1

Noted.
The min one is the only one I have no idea about, the other ones I can see.

That implies the wolves are in BS/Laser/Marl/Mill/Misty/Night/Squirrel/Wazza/Wind

Still a lot to unpack.

No worries, I wasnā€™t very vocal about it!

I was guessing 5 wolves but now Iā€™ve seen several people assume there are 4 wolves and Iā€™m kinda wondering what the reasoning is on that

Ftr this is roughly where Iā€™m at as well
Idk I can give it more thought later
Should maybe prioritize solving other slots since so many people are of the strong opinion Marshal is town but Iā€™m still iffy on it

Nah thereā€™s a way that works but Iā€™m not gonna say what I think about it

1x Parity Cop, or something similar to that.

Itā€™s not that broken, and regardless, the claim is real.

1 Like

I assumed 4 wolves left
But I donā€™t remember how many players we started with.

thatā€™s called Mentalist

also what if they are both mafia lol

1 Like

We started with 23
And I assumed ~6 wolves with room for a neutral or LW since OP said they may exist and itā€™s a large-ish game
But tbf it could be like, 4 packwolves, Vulgard, + a neut
I donā€™t really care if thereā€™s a neut or not at the moment since theyā€™d be impossible to distinguish from town as far as Iā€™m concerned

1 Like

i think windā€™s marshal push comes from town

/vote mistyx @Nyarchmage

If you see a point in outing/figuring out the exact role, go ahead

Yeah theyā€™re not but sure. If Iā€™m wrong, kill them both :shrug:

Valid!

Iā€™m not sitting here forever going through Marshals iso but Iā€™ve gotten far enough to see this post qith no followup lol

Like this is all the followup I see

Is this actually the reason Marshal has me at the bottom of her reads? Because she didnā€™t even put eevee at the bottom of her reads with me so idk what to make of that

I referenced this a couple hours ago when talking about Marshal complaining about my misinterpretation of whatever

But she still didnā€™t let go of her vague scumread on me for unexplained reasons and I donā€™t like it

so hereā€™s an explanation on some of marshals reads, and she did actually say something about wisdom which does not read as ā€œI havenā€™t paid attention to this slotā€ if she paid enough attention to disagree with them

She still gives no explanation as to why Iā€™m scum

Idk I donā€™t feel like scrolling more because I donā€™t think Iā€™ll even see anything to convince me otherwise

Thereā€™s inconsistency and reads that donā€™t seem to have reasoning so uh
Yeah sheā€™s probably still a wolf and isnā€™t engaging with me because itā€™s inevitably going to result in me wolfreading her more
The annoying thing is that she did exactly this in like two previous games where she wolfed against me and I called her out early when others were willing to towncore her

So I feel justified

1 Like

even if a maf dies itā€™s unlikely they figure out that Vulgard is a lost wolf imo so he might as well just not bus

and he did go to Arete, If his motive was to bus just to get recruited then why switch?

i donā€™t think JC gets killed by scum if heā€™s leading town off a cliff

i feel like if alana/marshal/wisdom are actually all town then i think squirrel probably needs to go just by poe because the reasons i have for clearing him are pretty superficial at this point

1 Like

Well the thing is since Vulgard did go to Arete, itā€™s possible he was watching the thread and decided not to bus in the end :person_shrugging: he went to Arete specifically when the Marshal wagon gained traction, which would fit with your theories of Vulgard wanting to avoid a bus.

I do think thereā€™s a much more efficient way Vulgard couldve joined wolfchat without bussing a partner but I donā€™t want to say it yet because Iā€™m still thinking things through, and I donā€™t want people to misinterpret or impulsively act on what I say without evaluating the situation for themselves.

1 Like

I already said earlier that JC was a townkill, I donā€™t see why scum kill him

So wolves killed no one?? What

i did kinda think he might be a wolf at eod but thatā€™s a pretty bad shot from town tbh
instead of just shooting the counterwagon for example

Or accidentally killed their wolf mate, who was also deep in some peopleā€™s PoE?

derpclear denied