I don’t know if I want to play another game for a while, just in general. May take time off. I felt myself dragging on Day 1, and I wasn’t having fun…and when I tried to have some fun and vibe I got scumread for it…so yeah it makes it rough to play.
1 Like
The fact that everyone is blind about the roles is the base of this game’s mechanic. Even if you say that it is part of what makes this game mafsided, I can’t say anything about it.
I understand that rolewise, this setup is indeed mafsided, and I understand if you hate this game specifically, given what happened to you.
Having that said, please give those setups a chance. If they are to pass the review system, then it shouldn’t be too disgusting.
AFAICR, Icibalus said she made two mistakes while reviewing my setup:
- Not noticing how the tie-breaker was handled
- (Somehow) not noticing the Even Night PGO
The fake greencheck was approved, but Osie’s “fake redcheck” isn’t fake at all. His role was “Name Cop”; it is a useless ability that only tells his target’s role name. It was his decision to interpret it as a redcheck, hence why he said he was “~75% sure” that Moka was evil.
Ya, this one is my fault. I forgot to mention that your ability devolves after each use.
…in hindsight I could have given you a refund had you asked for one.
I did.
Wait, what?
Hang on. I’m going to check it.
1 Like
I specifically said “You didn’t give me this about my role changing until it was too late for me to change my questions, can I get maybe 4 more questions?” and you said no.
1 Like
Okay. You’re right. I’m just a terrible host.
Your judgements are justified.
1 Like
Like I said though, that wasn’t my main gripe, the fake green in this type of game is my biggest gripe.
Everything else just got amplified with it.
I think the questions idea was super cool but potentially simpler roles were needed and less other confusing elements for town like godfathers.
It didn’t really matter to mafia that we didn’t know our abilities cuz we knew each other and knew we had a factional night kill, our strongest ability.
6 Likes
Deffo wasn’t awful though
The only thing I can do now is just apologize to you for not giving you extra questions after that delayed feedback. I don’t know what else to add to this.
–I can’t do anything about the fake greencheck though. It was approved by the reviewer, and that passive is literally as useless as Blackmaster’s passive, except in the niche scenarios, which just happened to happen to you.
1 Like
Kudos to @Simon
Yeah… I really need to tone my craziness down when it comes to creating setups.
…then again, this version is actually also somewhat toned down. The original setup had a “Multi-Cop” whose feedback accuracy depends on the amount of targets. Then both Ici and I decided that it was too OP after all, and then we ended up making the Multitasker.
PGO breaking the game and the hosts sanity any percent speedrun
1 Like
Ngl the PGO just sped the game up a day, I don’t see how town would get a member of scum executed today anyway
1 Like
their will was already broken
1 Like
ill be honest
idk how i was gonna guess my role
wolves were lucky i died
i was gonna use my night ability on hippo lmao
2 Likes
votes wrong, losing the the game
“the game was lost because leafia said shade and discredit a lot”
Never change
The absolute state of victim blaming
1 Like
u all suck haha
2 Likes
forum mafia players
people who accept why they lost and improve
two groups that share no members
2 Likes