Questions FM - GAME OVER (Mafia Victory)

but like not rn
im playing video games

1 Like

Alright, please do get back to me on that.

Hello Leafy! Mind giving me some thoughts?

@Leafia Specifically, could you do this for me?

Hmmm, going to go out on a limb here and give Aelin a townlean.

Could you give some analysis on this? Iā€™d like to hear your thoughts

Well,the only ones that I currently have are a townlean on both you and Aelin. There isnā€™t that much to work with at this point Iā€™m afraid.

Alright, well could you go read some of the other players I mentioned. Iā€™m not really getting a lot to work with here.

Null on all four of them at the moment, although maybe a townlean on Kiiruma due to that question help he gave. Even if it eventually proved fruitless.

Would you mind reading them for me, then reporting back your thoughts?

Her reasoning for scumreading you just felt like it came from a villagery PoV.

As soon as I can find the time, Iā€™ll do that.

1 Like

Thank you for your cooperation

Hey, Jake, what are your thoughts on Leafia?

Juat reread Lefiaā€™s ISO, feels a bit slim. Iā€™m willing to throw her a bone for now, but I am waiting for more from her.

zzz

if you never do this

im never doing this
simple as

Back on my laptop, letā€™s go through this.

Cutting down on a wall of quotes here

I donā€™t see it, I think in the context of these posts, they fit well into the thread. Care to elaborate on this point?

Could you give a clearer example of this? The posts you quoted donā€™t seem particularly relevant or jointed to that point.

Yeah, not particularly proud about this one. It was poorly crafted and poorly worded. Looking back on it, I probably should have said ā€œYour argument relies on me being scum, it does not demonstrate that I am scum.ā€

I think the following are two important contextual quotes.

The first response, from Eli, was that scum!jake would have been able to predict that his method would get him townread.
I responded saying that I agreed, and that would have been the reason why scum!jake would have revealed his method, but I later said in the same post that the downside to revealing the method would have been that the town would have benefited from it as well, as opposed to keeping it a secret for the scumteam to utilize by themselves.
Eli responded to this, saying that my method would not have actually helped, and in fact was a waste of questions.
I argued back that if it only wasted the townā€™s resources, then it wouldnā€™t have actually gotten me townread.
This argument continues on beyond the scope that Iā€™ve described, I recommend that anyone interested go and read this argument in full, because that will give more context for these snippets of conversation, and will leave you less likely to misinterpret my quotes here as they are a part of a larger argument not shown
Now then, I feel like Aelin has indirectly misrepresented me here, as the two quotes she have chosen seem to contradict each other, when in context they are a reasonable response to my debate partner.

I have responded, as above. Feel free to review it, and respond to it.

Not especially, itā€™s just something Iā€™m going to continue looking at moving forward. If you simply just donā€™t agree that theyā€™re awkward, Iā€™m not going toā€¦ convince you they are, lol

it seems like youre doing a lot to seem helpful without actually helping
i cant give more because, i dont know if youve noticed, this game is less than 500 posts long.

ok

first off, i read the entire thing
i didnt say that they were scummy via them contradicting each other, i just wanted to point out that they were tonally bad and not a towny thought process because youre simply minimizing the point viaā€¦ well, its not entirely a strawman, but it pretty much feels like it.

Do you think I did this intentionally and/or in bad faith? Donā€™t just reply ā€œyesā€ if thatā€™s the case, say which one.