Questions FM - GAME OVER (Mafia Victory)

Forum Games Completed
,
#441

If I am doing a lot of things which seem helpful but aren’t, could you provide me an example of that, and an explanation of why?

Ah, I misinterpreted your angle there.
It doesn’t ping me as being particularly non-town, the first quote seems like a town member is thinking through the actions of a scum member in a similar position, and what they would need to consider
The second quote seems like a reasonable followup question, as in the town member is essentially asking “Why would the scum reveal it if it would have been a bad outlook?”

It’s not exactly a strawman, but it does look like I am elaborating on an assumption that might have gone unspoken had I not brought it up.

Well I don’t know if you did it intentionally or not, maybe I do think you did it in good faith. What I do know is that it looks like misrepresentation.

#442

D1 Vote Count

Voted Voter Count
Hippopablompoyeetus GoodQuestion, JakeTheWolfie 2/7
Kiiruma Hippopablompoyeetus, Jarek 2/7
Blizer Kiiruma 1/7
EliThePsycho YoubutWorse 1/7
Jarek Blizer 1/7
JakeTheWolfie Aelin 1/7
YoubutWorse EliThePsycho 1/7
[Not voting] clonedcheese, eevee, MokaJoe, Leafia 4
#443

I am here and have not read anything

on the flip side i seem to have a decent idea about my role

2 Likes
#444

Would you mind doing some reading for me? Specifically on a highposter.

#445

later

#446

look at allll those wagons!

#447

I feel like were still at the beginning stage of the game, not even like d1 I just mean it feels like were still in the first 6 hours. Almost nothing has been done besides aelin and jake and eli actually reading some people and I don’t entirely know what to do about it.

#448

I believe that we need to start consolidating our votes. I recommend starting with Hippo here, as I am not finding them all too convincing.

#449

i just quoted the ones i saw
i cant tell if youre just being oblivious or are just trying to annoy me into putting reading you off

i mean
you dont need every single person to townread you
you just need enough to go “oh, he’s putting in effort. guess they’re town.” so that youre not on the chopping block

GTH, which one? Is it bad faith or good faith?

1 Like
#450

Replying to this for now so that I can read it when I have more time.

Aka: after both playoff games.

#451

@Aelin

What do you think of HipHopAnonymous?

#452

i dont really value it as a member of the music community tbhtbh

1 Like
#453

I am genuinely curious here, and I am honestly trying to see this FYPOV. Could you give me an explanation as to why I seemed helpful, when I was not?

Yeah, that’s a fair point.

I’m not sure what your intentions were. If I had to say, I think that you were engaged in a good-faithed analysis of me.

#454

Same

1 Like
#455

afsahdaowdoij
heavy sigh
what
is the
point of mafia

#456

Good Question

1 Like
#457

:wowee:

#458

low-effort hippo d1 is entirely nai and id have to take a look at who’s on them because people who have played with hippo before should be at least vaguely aware of this

2 Likes
#459

GQ, are you new to forum mafia? Do you have experience with hippo or resembling mediums?

#460

I played with him in Mario Sorceror’s and we were both town.

The only thing I remember was coming up with 50 nicknames for him that started with the word “Hip”

I clearly have the right priorities.