Ok, takes:
Brakuren’s a townlean for the aforementioned Treasure/Zorvo comparison.
The interaction of Magnus trying to catch Dum in a contradiction reads to me as town scumreading town off semantics. At the very least, I’m going to townread Magnus for that.
As such, I do not like how OK tried to capitalize on that. Combine this with how…off post #25 is to me (it reads like a half-hearted acknowledgement even after a night of thinking on it), as well as how stagnant their wagon has been, and I’m willing to file OK as my top scumread at the moment.
I don’t really know what to make of Geyde. Much of their posting is pure reaction, but that makes sense given their interaction with Brakuren being less than friendly.
Zone is a weak townlean: I can’t imagine a wolf actively making their reads hard to read.
My only take on Hippo is that they voted me for 4/10 reasoning: I wasn’t the only one making the “flimsiest reasoning” joke (though that would be lost in an ISO), and I don’t like how the wagon on me seems to be a pressure vote that works backwards to justify itself. This is how I got hard scumread in Stellaris: Tutuu started a joke vote, then mafia Baker threw some flimsy reasoning on top to push me, and the wagon kept going.
Edit: Thought Frost was the one who accused Dum off semantics; turns out that was Magnus. This has been updated to reflect that.