Secret Palpatine - Completed - Jedi (Whysper, Jarek, Jane, AtNoName, Squirrel, Crichard) Win

[ATNoName]

@ATNoName

Ok, even if I end up misinterpreting, I end up going with a 0.6% by your math. Why shouldn’t I just skip, pass it to me and pick someone that I trust?

like I’m playing FM to get better at the game. Even if I misclear and end up losing the game, it’s at the very least better than trying to be perfect with my reads.

[Isolde]

@ATNoName

@Wazza

It was literally 3am, also no blue chancellor is confirmed, that’s correct, but what would you rather, a random player who can be any alignment having a touch as the president to drop stuff or simply letting the player who has already touched the deck touch it again to see the result. One is clearly more better than the other, you seem like you’ve played SH before, you should know this by now.

Amelia is the definition of a random hand because they never got a choice in deciding R or B. You’re presenting it as somehow they magically influenced Jane to discard R.

@Wazza

In the case Amelia is scum and I am town there is only a 15.126% chance of a blue policy being enacted unless they decide to enact it anyway
In the case Amelia is town and I am scum this chance is the same unless I choose to enact a blue policy anyway
In the case we’re both Town there is a 66.006% chance that we enact a blue policy
In the case we’re both Scum there is a 0.606% chance that a blue policy is enacted

So now I have a question for you, considering you love math so much, do you actually think there’s a point in us both as scum picking each other, or are you just saying that to seem like you’re doing something with “proof” to back it up, my pessimism is justified.

The thing is your cases point is actually just straight up useless because it is influenced by the player and therefore would constitute as WIFOM which I’m completely avoiding. My point is if I decided me/CRich, not only is the chance of Jedi policy passing basically increased FMPOV, but I also get to pick and resolve my POE and advance my plans of having Seth’s dream of passing all 5 Jedi win be a thing. See how social play comes in handy in this game?

And you call be a Sith.

[Isolde]

Your more then just a dream crusher.

[Isolde]

AT are you trying to say getting R/R/R or claiming to have got it is wolfy?
@ATNoName

[Isolde]

@Amelia

So which of us two do you think is more likely to be Sith

ATNoName

[Amelia]

so you know the post is about why it doesn’t make sense for us to pick each other if we’re both wolves

And its not about you

[Isolde]

@Wazza

@Silviu200530

Why did Amelia never get a choice in deciding Red or Blue

Jane received RBB
Jane dropped R
Amelia received BB
Amelia dropped B
B is enacted

@ATNoName

@Silviu200530

Very sorry if I’m being oblivious. Why did Amelia never get a choice in deciding Red or Blue? And I’m assuming Jane was vice president? And what did Wazza say that the last sentence is about whenever Amelia influenced Jane to discard the sith card or not?

I feel like I’ve missed so many things when I’m omnipresent in this thread.

Jane claimed BBR and discarded R which leaves Amelia with BB.

@Wazza

No I’m not
I’m sorry if you’re looking at the amount of math and percentages that are there and interpret it as me thinking it’s simply just 50/50, I think you’re blind. If we wanted to expand it further and talk about every other nook and crevice then we’d be here all night, that’s why I constricted it to only the choice of me and Amelia with proof of the deck, reliability on what has been claimed and why you’re wrong

Ok, even if I end up misinterpreting, I end up going with a 0.6% by your math. Why shouldn’t I just skip, pass it to me and pick someone that I trust?

Both show intent to reply to Silviu first.
Wazza replied first and gave a better response.
This might not mean anything but I just wanna point it out.

[ATNoName]

@Isolde

Look good?
Sharing my thoughts and posting how I normally post (like a mother fucker) is looking good.

I wish people call me that in every game.

“Hey Seth you look good!”
Instead of
“He’s Seth, he’s normally wolfy!”

also the problem with your philosophy is that it’s aligned with how wolves would want to win the game.

@Isolde

And you call be a Sith.

meh. more like my reads changed over the course of the game and I figured you lack way too much awareness to be a sith.

@Isolde

AT are you trying to say getting R/R/R or claiming to have got it is wolfy?
@ATNoName

It’s a lot complicated and more on the math side because while RRR one of the main possiblities. I think in the case of BRR, they would attempt to say its RRR. They could be right, but we don’t know either way choosing me/CRich would increase the chance the Jedi would pass in the case of BRR.

@Amelia

so you know the post is about why it doesn’t make sense for us to pick each other if we’re both wolves

And its not about you

I already answered the question. I did misinterpret, so what? my decision of skipping over to me stands.

[Isolde]

@ATNoName

also the problem with your philosophy is that it’s aligned with how wolves would want to win the game.

Yeah man you caught me red handed!
I’m doing what a wolf do man!
You figured out I wanted to get 5 Jedi cards as soon as possible so Palpatine doesn’t even get 3 Sith Cards and lose the game.

Yep. You figured it out! I’m throwing!
Congratulations!

[Isolde]

@ATNoName

meh. more like my reads changed over the course of the game and I figured you lack way too much awareness to be a sith.

Oh so I am a Jedi now?

[Amelia]

But

The original posts asks why it makes sense for me and wazza to pick each other over anyone else

I don’t remember you actually answering that instead of just calling the post meaningless because it had wifom

[Isolde]

@Isolde

@Squirrel2412

Wait is flavorclaiming even illegal

Ki-Adi-No

Also if no one noticed this was a flavour soft in the beginning.

[Isolde]

I was hoping someone was going to point it out but clearly no one did.

[Amelia]

I mean if you read the OP, sith get flavorclaims

So

[ATNoName]

@Isolde

Yeah man you caught me red handed!
I’m doing what a wolf do man!
You figured out I wanted to get 5 Jedi cards as soon as possible so Palpatine doesn’t even get 3 Sith Cards and lose the game.

Yep. You figured it out! I’m throwing!
Congratulations!

wtf are you saying? In an FM game, town want to hunt wolf and wolves wants to look towny. How would you distinguish the two?

@Isolde

Oh so I am a Jedi now?

I mean right now I’m conflicted, but before I was thinking you’re Jedi.

@Amelia

But

The original posts asks why it makes sense for me and wazza to pick each other over anyone else

I don’t remember you actually answering that instead of just calling the post meaningless because it had wifom

Already said, scum have a tendency of choosing their scumbuddies over the other, but I said it somewhere that it comes down to what Amelia think and how we interpret it.

[Isolde]

@ATNoName

It’s a lot complicated and more on the math side because while RRR one of the main possiblities. I think in the case of BRR, they would attempt to say its RRR. They could be right, but we don’t know either way choosing me/CRich would increase the chance the Jedi would pass in the case of BRR.

What makes you so confident in CRichard?

[ATNoName]

@Isolde

What makes you so confident in CRichard?

His post feels more genuine than just throwing idea into the thread.

[Silviu200530]

@Isolde

“Hey Seth you look good!”
Instead of
“He’s Seth, he’s normally wolfy!”

Seth, you look cute

[Amelia]

[ATNoName]

@ATNoName

wtf are you saying? In an FM game, town want to hunt wolf and wolves wants to look towny. How would you distinguish the two?

like granted this isn’t FM, so I was literally just spending the entire early game deciding whether or not you really believed in passing 5 Jedi policies or not.