Serpent and the Swordsman (Thread 2) - Deathkissed Win [4/15]

[Hazardwaste]

Only cross bows

[Artemis]

Blood on the Glocktower.

[Hazardwaste]

Let me go find mags whisper log

[L.una]

I think the simplest world to start from is assuming magnus is town, which means tutuu is town, and start building worlds from there to see what that leaves us

Ojo/Pithag in that world had to do something

[L.una]

I don’t really buy Ojo? The story tellers said that the kills would be less useful if it missed than a single kill of their choice, but the kills would be better than a pithag. I would probably kill a tinker and a townsfolk instead of two townsfolk if an Ojo missed, but uh

that leaves the same problem with pithag but worse
weird

[Hazardwaste]

Unless evil was really behind

[L.una]

the problem with that is it’s bmr, town gets rare information in the first place

[Hazardwaste]

I am fucking stumped… this game is so weird

[L.una]

we don’t have a lot of info yeah

[Hazardwaste]

I think we have AT least one evil dead if not 2. So we are looking at 2 or 3 evils alive.
Did we think kiiruma was a good bishop? Lets go back to that?

[tutuu]

i have 2 very strong arguments for why im town btw

i can deliver them now but im being lazy and/or might not be necessary

but if evils try to push me - good luck bucko. my finger is on the trigger

[L.una]

Givem

[Kiiruma]

If Litten is neutral then Litten’s just doing chaos for no reason (Luckily there’s no mafia or neutral in BotC)

[tutuu]

ok sure

1st one is: i am the only one who knew how my role works this game:

@tutuu

no

each night except the first i pick a player. if i die, my choice goes through. its different than in the party game. i dont get to see the other kills

i picked magnus n2, bionic n3, artemis n4

magnus, artemis and luna didnt:

@Artemis

@Magnus

I’m unsure why the latter wasn’t.

Ravenkeeper can choose any time after death, I believe?

@Magnus

This is fair, yeah. It matters for the Exorcist because that actively could affect the night normally.

@L.una

It’s an unfair advantage for Raven keeper to see night kills before, and it’s confirming them if you keep the thread close till they pick

thats because they dont need to. im the only one who knew the addendum added to my role (to make it function for asynchronous forum setting)

2nd argument is: my neighboring whispers with baker

if i am demon, i can easily give baker bluffs. and then he doesn’t need to flail and die spectacularly like he did. but most importantly - do u guys remember that whole fiasco with our whispers? he pinged me itt, asking me why im not responding to him claiming mafia to me. litten went all about baker potentially being a pit hag who misunderstood his role (he claimed ojo and pithag to me). then baker got miffed at me for outing them, said i put him in trouble coz he was just joking around. outed my claims without my consent. if me and baker are w/w, what exactly did we gain from doing all that fiasco, what exactly did we achieve?

[Hazardwaste]

Wait theres a xhange to raven keeper?

[Artemis]

@tutuu

1st one is: i am the only one who knew how my role works this game:

This isn’t a good argument. You could have gotten it as a bluff and asked how it worked so you could claim it.

[tutuu]

L bozo

[Hazardwaste]

Whats the change???

[L.una]

if may is good it technically doesn’t have to be a Hui Jing

[L.una]

Here’s an elaborate world