[SFM] Assorted Universes Greatest Idea Mafia - Day 5 (4/17) - WEREWOLVES + SURVIVOR WINS

Hmmm, you may be right about that.

Iā€™m paykng attention to you too Wazza.

Iā€™d agree on my voice mattering since my reads have been pretty decent this game especially if CRichard is scum

1 Like

I agree. Your reads have been pretty decent that game.

This game I mean.

/vote CRichard @Host_Account_2

iā€™m signing off for the night and want to make sure I put a vote down. I donā€™t find the reasoning for his attack on me believable, I explained my reads on moose/jarek, aelin in all likelihood town by mech.

Oh nice a thunderdome. Let the best one win.

Interesting that catbae didnā€™t vote Bellatrix, who was the first to vote on catbae.

Interesting that he says this, yet never tried to engage with me on why I voted him.

That being said, catbae/Moose and catbae/Jarek donā€™t make sense from where Iā€™m at. Seeing as catbae pushed on Moose with ClonedCheese for bad reasons and likely agenda.
Catbae/Jarek doesnā€™t make sense, seeing as the former didnā€™t defend Jarek when Moose explained their Jarek suspicion.

Why catbae is aligned with Porscha.
They made votes on Trochi with little/no reasoning behind them. Iā€™ll quote the posts where they made votes on Trochi, yet what is notable is that they didnā€™t express scum reads before making the votes.

Notice how these votes have pretty much no reasons to vote Trochi, not even a scum read before hand.

1 Like

Why catbae and ClonedCheese are aligned.
They both didnā€™t show any signs of caring about the wagons at EoD1, which were both town.

Notice that ClonedCheese is probably TMIing Trochi as town, yet at EoD1 does he act to save Trochi by voting on Derps who was the counter wagon? No, they were off wagon.
Guess who else was off the EoD1 main wagons? Catbae of course.

Final Day 1 VC

voted voters count
Derps Bellatrix, Intensify, Kiiruma, CRichard, Italy, Aelin 6/9
Trochilidae Wazza, Jarek, Porscha, Moose, Derps, Leafia 6/9
wazza Trochi 1/9
Moose clonedcheese 1/9
Aelin Gorta 1/9
CRichard Lucky 1/9

Both ClonedCheese and Catbae have shown that they didnā€™t care about the wagons, as long as it wasnā€™t one of their team being put on the chopping block.
Now compare that to D2 and D3.

The fact that catbae wasnā€™t on the EoD1 wagons, yet was voting on the counter wagon to Cloned and Porscha on D2 and D3 respective tell me that this pattern makes the most sense.

Catbae as scum didnā€™t bother to get involved with the EoD1 wagons, as we know by now that Trochi and Derps are both town. During D2 and D3, the town put ClonedCheese and Porscha on the block each day respectively. They both flipped mafia. If catbae was town or even scum not mafia, they almost certainly would have joined the Cloned and Porscha wagons as they have no reason to stay off their wagons, if town/scum not mafia was their alignment.

From Occamā€™s Razor, itā€™s most likely that catbae is of the mafia alignment.

Cloned only quotes catbae once the entire time they are alive.
Now lets look at who Cloned voted.

Note that Cloned never pushed catbae even once while alive. Whatā€™s even more damning is that Cloned and Catbae also never tried to solve each otherā€™s alignments.

As far as Iā€™m aware, Porscha didnā€™t vote on catbae as well though Iā€™ll check to be 100% sure.

They only voted Trochi, who as we know was town.

Note that Porscha says catbae has a strong D1, yet that was never elaborated on while they were alive.
Thatā€™s a textbook example of wolf taking about their partner and being afraid to commit to a read on their partner, in case one of them flips to avoid tying both of them together.

1 Like

Also this went no where now I mention it. It comes across as a wolf trying to dirty Bellatrix by trying to invent a world in which Bellatrix/Cloned are team, which doesnā€™t make sense seeing as Cloned/Porscha are mafia/mafia and Bellatrix helped to bury Porscha 6 feet under.

To everyone who is alive.
Please read my case on catbae before deciding to vote on either myself or catbae.

Do I count
Not alive physically but mentally Iā€™m thriving

You donā€™t count as alive when it comes to voting.

This is deadism

1 Like

I made a case on catbae. Let me know what you think once you read through it.