if garfooled is town we had v/v wagons all day, and they ended up v/v/v
wolves’ favorite thing to do in situations like this is to do nothing. they just love to do nothing and let town implode
this was posted 5 hours before EoD. how come you didn’t vote anybody after this?
@Garfooled why didn’t you self-pres?
@bystander hi, where’s your head at? who do you think are the wolves?
(apologies if these questions have already been answered, i’m backreading)
so yeah actually if gar is V i would be very cautious of zug. and bystander is probably just always a wolf if gar is town
i need to re-evaluate leafia too oh fuck my life man. im feeling uneasy lol. none of my townreads are rock-solid anymore
maybe i was too generous on my leafia townread?
i think magnus is mega town but zug has been suspecting them for a while? am i supposed to be sheeping zug here?
zug feels mega towny but his actions makes sense from a wolf pov who can just sit there and entertain himself while we all eat each other?
bystander:
@Zugzwang did you ask me during the previous day phase to link you examples of magnus posts that I found passionate (ergo towny)? i swear you did, and i thought i didnt reply, i went back to look for them to reply now but i’m not finding them. did i dream about this? lmao
Zug definitely posted that question sometime yesterday, I doubt we’re both having the same Mandela effect.
IIRC rhea had leafia as a top townread and i thought that was odd because iirc there wasn’t that much of an explanation for it, and i dont think rhea was familiar with leafia. now that i remember it, at the time i thought rhea thought leafia was the vig and that’s why she did that, so i had to stay quiet about it. let me see if i can find it
Rhea correct me if I’m wrong but I skimmed your ISO and this is the only thing you shared about Leafia between having her as lean town and then progressing to put her as top town
How come? Did you think she was the vig?
Oh fuck me man why did I say this. I should have kept quiet about it and not give her an out if she’s a wolf. Towning is tough man you need to like … you can’t be fully transparent. Although it’s nice to be. But you need to think like an interrogator, you need to be a little bit evil
It’s a good question because then even if that was the answer Rhea was planning to give, it would need to be justified using reasoning in the thread. This is more harmful to evils than town because it could give away partner TMI from a wolf or prospective purity from a villager. If you hadn’t given that option, Rhea could’ve just given that response without follow-up reasoning.
Here, imo:
(quote broke when i quoted the spoiler)
to me the bomb shell post had a lot of passion in it, at least the way i read or, or imagined magnus reading it out loud
magnus never wolves with bystander i think we can all agree
if leafia is mafia she’s probably with rhea
if zug is mafia i wanna say he’s with bystander
gar + rhea was our prime team from yesterday. maybe jail should have shot gar instead of pandora although hindsight is 20/20 and i also thought pandora is an obv wolf after i saw the someone flip
bystander + rhea seems like a fine team to me
bystander + gar is … eh. both of them just lollygagging?
what was zug’s teammate suggestion for wolf magnus again?
magnus gar or magnus leafia mm
magnus gar isn’t egregious yeah. i think their actions are sensible. mag did ask for gar to not be chopped and to be shot instead. maybe they anticipated the vig wouldnt shoot gar although idk how you’d anticipate that. maybe paranoia from someone flipping v?
I’m not really suspicious of Garfooled anymore, au contraire. I struggle to see a wolf willing to die and then protesting when they’re saved.
why were you expecting to die N1, even so early on in the day?
at night I tried it for a bit
I came up with (from most to least likely)
Tutuu
Jail
Magnus
Rhea
Gar
(big gap)
others
I expected the vig to be pretty invested, which means a lot of pressure to solve - which is why I thought Leafia/Pandora/Bystander were unlikely.
Gar didn’t claim under pressure and was worried about being shot - I think this should’ve been given more weight than I did at the time, but that’s why it’s under the others
You were very invested, and didn’t spew yourself not vig
Jail, Magnus, and Rhea were in that order because wolves can’t be the vig, and that was the order of my reads
Nothing special there that differentiates them beyond that tho
I considered Magnus giving advice to the vig, but it seemed like they’d reasonably do that as vig so I didn’t read into that
Nobody else seemed immediately overtly threatening at the beginning of the game, to be honest. I underestimated several of your abilities.
I think insincere vs genuine better captures it, yeah
wasn’t sure till near the end
when I had settled on Someone, he was already top wagon, and I figured there’s more to be gained by letting things play out with close wagons, rather than making the result look decided
