Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 2 - Days 3-7

[Achromatic]

Funny because a lot of people, including spf, agreed with my read that the threadstate was shitty. Because it was. Tbh it has remained that way most of the game so day 1 was clearly just a false positive

Pulling away?

Heisenberg (7): Hally, spf, Outedwolf, Gyrlander, eliza, GaulSoodman, Achromatic
katze (5): guavagudetama, min, nightingale, SaulGoodman, Rue

Sir this is a wendy’s

[Zorvo]

Ooooo what a play!

Sufdaddy with the desperate last effort wing it push.

[Zorvo]

@sufdaddy
Top 5 Town?

[Zorvo]

Oh wow look, my a person in my PoE is for sure getting executed today, Wind is technically more null then null wolf but this was all based on my previous readslist.

As I said I’d rather Min be executed allot more then Wind and what is really making me squint an eye is that Rue is voting Wind over Min.

@Rue
Didn’t you have concern on Min yesterday?

[Zorvo]

@Rue

To answer the question, it was because I had previously asked Min if he thought there had to be a wolf between katze and Arctic, and he said he did. When he came into today trying to bury Ruby and defending katze, it sent off alarms for me.

[sufdaddy]

@Achromatic

Funny because a lot of people, including spf, agreed with my read that the threadstate was shitty.

this is a ridiculous lie

@spf

hmm i disagree and think that you might be assuming the wolves would be capable of having more thread control than they actually do in a 25 player game on d1

@spf

for one, basing reads off of threadstate in a 25 player role madness game is a genuinely fucking awful way to solve and it should not be the foundation for any reads at all

@spf

if u are basing ur reads in a 25p mild bastard role madness game on d1 based off of “threadstate” then u might as well be reading tea leaves or investing in ur horoscope because it will be equally as accurate to give u a good impression of the game

it is a mild pet peeve how casually “threadstate” is thrown around to justify a view of the game doesnt really make sense lol

@Achromatic

Pulling away?

Heisenberg (7): Hally, spf, Outedwolf, Gyrlander, eliza, GaulSoodman, Achromatic
katze (5): guavagudetama, min, nightingale, SaulGoodman, Rue

Sir this is a wendy’s

I already covered this in my initial post about your eod1, you crossposted with Rue switching from heisenberg to katze.

@sufdaddy

went back to read EOD1

achro is probably a wolf

he was defending heisenberg, attacking eliza, pushing for gyrlander. stood by and did nothing while katze became a wagon, then when heisenberg started pulling away he suddenly votes heisenberg when it was 7-4 (crossposted with Rue switching from heisenberg to katze)

fwiw, the wagons were 7-6 heisenberg when i came in and voted heisenberg about 35 minutes to deadline. (memes immediately calling it a scummy vote probably villagy, as a sidenote.)

heisenberg wagon started to runaway a bit after this, achro was kinda just … there, not really doing anything meaningful. think he felt stuck and didnt really know what to do, figured berg was likely dying and just stayed on for the cred. It’s never super clear WHY he votes heisenberg, the reasoning with teh vote doesnt make a ton of sense imo.

but his eod1 looks pretty bad iyam.

if you’re a villager, you are being pretty disingenuous dude. I’m not going back and forth with you on a million posts, especially when you are arguing in bad faith.

[Zorvo]

I mean I think at that point ruby’s slot was un salvageable and in anti spew that entire day.

Nothing about Ruby pushes, cases or votes is AI during last day.

[Zorvo]

If you want AI, we look at the day Arctic was executed over Ruby.

[Zorvo]

@spf

gth i would probably vote in min

Roger That!

[Achromatic]

Fine then, but spf immediately apologized for that last comment and has other posts saying she thought the thread state wasnt good as did plenty of others.

I wont go back and forth with you either. Shrug.

[Sadbi]

Alison?

[min]

Dude

Wind was pushed by desd villagers

[min]

Nothing she’s said has been out of her wolf range either

[min]

@Zorvo

@spf

gth i would probably vote in min

Roger That!

…did you ignore the massive post that Zach quoted where spf wolf read wind?

[Achromatic]

[min]

I want zorvo to listen to me and my reasoning especially considering I’ve given more than enough reason as to why any villager would vote wind over me here

[min]

Someone has received a track btw

[min]

Well

They WILL receive one after eod

[Sadbi]

I want gifts

[min]

I can also still claim

My role is extremely powerful and protown and I feel like my death will be pretty hard of a blow to town especially over someone who is probably a wolf