Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 2 - Days 3-7

[Sadbi]

[Gyrlander]

I wouldn’t be surprised if katze and Memes are both villagers, btw.

[sufdaddy]

who do you think are the wolvesi n that world?

[katze]

@spf

katze - i am bad at reading katze which in turns means that it is difficult for me to comment on katze’s alignment with any level of certainty, but what i will say is that none of the arguments i have seen for her being a wolf are even remotely convincing or good. i think katze has been fine in the sense that i saw sparks of towniness from her throughout d1 (with the way she handled pressure and etc) and i think she has been approaching today in a mildly towny way with the fluidity and paranoia about locking herself into an incorrect push on arctic, and the way she has shown an openness to changing and playing around with her worldview (like switching to a zack push to see if arctic would take the bait, etc). i don’t think that it’s impossible for katze to be a wolf but i’d really rather not go there today, especially in the absence of any good reasons

@spf

katze is making post over post showing genuine doubt over arctic’s alignment and trying to come to a world where arctic is town

arctic is making post after post with confirmation biased and flawed logic hard tunneling on katze without even a perceivable hint of doubt or self-reflection that he could be pushing incorrectly

in the dynamic between the two of them, it’s pretty obvious that katze is trying to solve arctic far more than the other way around. if katze/arctic are T v T and arctic flips V then it will be hard for me to feel bad due to him creating this gamestate for himself based on his own actions

if katze is maf and arctic is town and i just don’t see it, then gg to arctic i guess

spf spat fire, damn

she is my new favorite gay pink lady

[sufdaddy]

@Rue how polarized is seth? are you confident in your clear?

[sufdaddy]

@spf

i don’t think that it’s impossible for katze to be a wolf

i didn’t read anything else

only this

[katze]

thats just classic #TheFear from spf, u can ignore it

[sufdaddy]

[katze]

[Gyrlander]

Hmmm. In that world I’d expect wolves to be between Gorta, guava, Jack, Outedwolf, Rue and sufdaddy.

To be honest Gorta is getting a mild free pass (for now) because I’ve seen people say he’s likely Town. Guava more or less the same, mainly due to Achro saying he’s very towny if you read Ruby’s ISO. Jack, Outedwolf and YOU… I’m not sure. I actually townread Outedwolf and Jack at some point but I REALLY need to reevaluate. Rue might be my biggest townlean in that list.

You? I’ve got no fucking idea lol.

[Gyrlander]

To be honest considering how weak Town’s roles are I can easily believe Katze having that “TOOTH FAIRY” role. I’m more inclined to lynch Memes. As far as we know there are, at least, 2 more Witches that could have fake bleeds (this idea is reinforced by the fact that there has been someone poisoned).

[sufdaddy]

@Gyrlander

You? I’ve got no fucking idea lol.

[Rue]

I don’t think he’s polarized, but I don’t think he ever does what he did yesterday with the false quotes as a wolf. That was the point where I was convinced his tunnel on me was not just solely agenda.

[sufdaddy]

@guavagudetama

Just read Heisen’s posts
For 133 posts there’s… quite little that actually matters? Heisen seems to love shitposting.
Though what substance I did find I’m reading as town.
(Wolfread for making a m*rbius joke /j)

@guavagudetama

I’m gonna be real with you Pokemon Ruby and Sapphire I don’t understand most of the stuff Heisen said I just think they’re town because posts like #2684 and #2900 look like they make sense

I have a subhuman catboy brain and not a lot of this stuff makes sense to me yet but I’m trying my best and Heisen seems like a townie!

Seriously though I’ve read 2900 4 times and I still don’t actually get it but it looks town to me

[Gyrlander]

Don’t really know what your reads are, sufdaddy.

[katze]

yea his posts are not pretty

i still think those two are kinda villagery in the sense that i dont think thats how he’d defend a bro

but like

not sure how much id bet on it

[sufdaddy]

lean v
gyrlander
outedwolf
rue
sadbi

dunno, deferring to people who townread them
gorta
zorvo
min

jackrito
katze
memes

lean w
achro
guava

[sufdaddy]

order within tiers just alphabetical

[sufdaddy]

@katze

yea his posts are not pretty

i still think those two are kinda villagery in the sense that i dont think thats how he’d defend a bro

but like

not sure how much id bet on it

it seems like a nonsense read to me

wrote a bunch of words and said therefore heisenberg is v, even though nothing they said pointed to that in any real way

[sufdaddy]

@Ruby

Criteria will be off the top of my head

Night
Sadbi
GaulSoodman
Achromatic
Gyrlander

Think about that

the achro placement made me

it’s not followed up on, kinda came out of nowhere, later pushes on gaul who was above achro here. w/w energy