Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 1 - Days 1 & 2

Forum Games Completed
, ,
#7280

well

in one game there was a wolf role that was just a puppet account, if you executed it iirc it was flipless and nothing happened, it didnt count towards parity

in another there was a village role that started with an alt that bodyguarded said village role, and the villager could pass it around (it bodyguarded villagers and gave wolves a strongman shot). im not actually sure what happened if the alt in that game got yeeted? i forget how it would be removed from the game

i think those are the only two instances of additional-account roles in umineko games, rue might be able to fill in any gaps im forgetting? i think she’s played all the uminekos

so i dont think this one really falls under either, i assumed the SaulGoodman account would be the “host” account that if we needed to eliminate one specific one it’d be that one, but evidently that isnt the case

ive been mildly tempted to test to see if arctic actually functionally has two votes somehow – in the umineko with a puppet wolf account it did not actually have voting power – because i think if he did then i think it’d actually be more likely to be a village role, but im not sure how much id bet on that and it feels like a dangerous hostread to get wrong

and if it didnt i dont actually think it’d say much about his alignment

so shrug

#7281

VOTE: min

#7282

what’s your read on achro?

Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 2 - Days 3-7
#7283

hi eevee

do you have any words to say or are you going to just reply to this and disappear

#7284

hi katze

do you have any words to say or are you going to just reply to this and disappear

#7285

I think he’s more likely town than not, but it’s not a confident read.

Speaking of, @Achromatic, can you go into more detail about how gamestate has informed your reads?

Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 2 - Days 3-7
#7286
#7287

Has Gyrlander and Achro as the most likely scummies on their wagon at that time.

@Ruby with both of them being on Heisemberg, does it change your impression?

Do you think they are the likely bussers? If so? What does that mean for the Katze wagon, why two scum choose to bus Heisemberg instead of chopping Katze, if Katze is town?

#7288

now, let’s try to read Katze proper

#7289

thats pmuch where i am too, but seeing his name as one of the last on that wagon and now the last on kim made me go

Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 2 - Days 3-7
#7290

you caught me as i woke up

note changed as i thought achro and gaul swapped actually gaul liely bottom of that list at this point

Katze town worlds i have Gaul likely busser and maybe gyrl feel their vote on me was just a dumb to increase the volume i never saw a reason really when i skimmed their iso

(Yes i tryied isoing last night but honesly they are all to long to remember stuff soildly)

#7291

if people are interested in this we could probably try to organize me getting hammered with two of my 12 votes being from him? if i die at 12 then you have my thoughts on the mech implications

#7292

You have been doing this for. Like. Two days now

#7293

is it normal for gorta’s iso to be entirely “im gonna read katze now” without reading katze

#7294

Yes.

#7295

absolutely

#7296

fair enough

#7297

Why Gaul attempts to buss only to change it last minute though? When it is obvious it’d look bad when their partner flips wolf?

#7298

Gorta is literally the most difficult player to play with

#7299

nah he either makes himself an incredibly obvious villager somehow or dies

usually both once he survives to xylo