evil goon is kinda like poli
town doesn’t want to kill you because gf and locks you in
will spend resources to turn you back, which you can use to confirm townsfolk since a lot of townsfolk act earlier
ect ect
i need something that thoroughly contradicts my line of thought to let go of the mechanics i have about you and the incredibly poor timing of the thing
When reading felt like bionic may JMW were town, believed jarek goon claim, thought claiming lunatic was wild as evil (think I forgot to talk about zug in the wall) and thought someone going after travelers so hard would be a weird strat if they were evil
which kinda left a small group of people and wazza ice didn’t feel w/w
Votecount
| Nominator | Nominee | # | Voters |
|---|---|---|---|
| IcetFeelsPain | Bionic | 0 | |
| Atlas | May | 0 | |
| May | Atlas | 0 | |
| Mistyx | Jarek | 0 | |
| Sleep | 0 | ||
| — | |||
| Not Voting | 16 | Crazynuto, bystander, iamagummybear, Litten, IcetFeelsPain, Geyde, jmw, Bionic, Hazardwaste, Atlas, Jarek, Mistyx, May, Zugzwang, Someone, Wazza |
Not Voting (16): May, Crazynuto, bystander, iamagummybear, Litten, IcetFeelsPain, Geyde, jmw, Bionic, Hazardwaste, Atlas, Jarek, Mistyx, Zugzwang, Someone, Wazza
okay well
i dont really feel like repeating that one dreamer game so im gonna be annoyed if jarek is randomly lying as some good role
i am, in fact, an outsider, bys can confirm i claimed this shortly before jarek started softing
nominate jarek @Hearth
1 Like
Alright cool
VOTE: Jarek
every bone in my body is just
get that guy
get that guy right now
2 Likes
i dont really have an idea of why he’s doing this as evil which is annoying but i dont see why he would do this as good and i think him making a weird play as evil is more likely than bys randomly dying as evil n2 then fakeclaiming tinker
especially if shes anything but godfather in which case executing jarek is like ~fine anyway
1 Like
it’s impossible to have 3 outsiders in a base 1 game right?
1 Like
yeah
1 Like
it’s possible misty is trying to lock in jarek and get a kill but that will also become evident based off kills I think
So willing to just kill jarek
to be clear this is because bys is a first time player and i’ve seen jarek turbo himself as cerenovus
1 Like
i have been breathing heavily for the past five minutes
1 Like
my excitement waned like much earlier
You don’t have an actual argument here, you have mechanics (which are completely opaque to me) that you think vaguely point to me being evil and you’ve decided to stuff my behaviour into that mould. There is no reason to wolf the Lunatic as evil unless I am expressly pretending to be reaction testing the Lunatic claim, and that’s just as likely as being Good deciding to-
Actually, let me cite another game to you, one that Zug and I just played together. Anonymous game. He’s a Jailkeeper and messenger-like role, he has both abilities that can be used on separate people. He jailkeeps somebody, they plan together to have Zug message someone claiming lost wolf. The person claims wolf back to Zug, they have a short exchange, and then like halfway through the next day, Zug publicly exposes them in thread. Everybody involved in this exchange was town. Except the person Zug planned with, they were a wolf. Zug even mentioned that he likes doing things like that.
Having this information, I would have a very significant reason to think Zug was probably not the actual Lunatic, and was probably reaction testing me like he did to somebody in that anonymous game. Why would I try to make him play for evil if I were evil? That makes me “fail the reaction test”.
1 Like
you’re good at mafia
1 Like
he’s got a point may
maybe we need to execute you his point rhere has merit
1 Like
If you land on “you’re good at mafia” for the reason I would do something, it’s =rand.
hardclaiming lw to a random stranger is poor play