If I target the top half which currently has 8, I will get a minimum of 8 pings, but not a 9th because I am not in that half.
Of course all of this is making the assumption nothing interferes with my ability, which is a very big and unreliable assumption considering what Conroy’s ability did.
Eh, it is more that answer for one of those would be Arctic.
Ask me again when I start to paint my own world view.
As in… I think I described it before, but after I read enough of long-term aroac of the players and how they influence each other, at some point I see the game more like a puzzle or painting where it all falls into it’s own place together, and like in puzzle, even remaining pieces find own place, even if I didn’t read them whole game.
Think of it more like a dance, where people interact each other, and if you see few ancers, you can already guess what other people moves will be on the ball room.
That would be good moment to ask me for list like that.
I don’t think MD is a useless role but it does almost nothing this early in the game, especially as X-shot and with unannounced player groups.
And it can ping a total of 8 times if all of them move?
It can ping more than that, if some target others in the same half of the player list
You should be grateful for the role that you have to be honest
Killjoy intellectual capability has been limited and massacred and massacred again
Well I’m not super grateful that I claimed, but I know I’m not a priority kill because I’m PoE with a fishy role and also one that doesn’t threaten wolves until F5 or F3.
I mean if I activated tonight I could possibly detect the night kill, along with literally everyone else’s actions, which is why it isn’t useful to even try unless someone wants to track me. And tbh I’d be wary of someone asking me to activate specifically to track me since that’s like… Not useful either. It proves I’m not lying about my role but it doesn’t prove my alignment, so it’s not useful for a tracker to waste time on, either.
If I were tracker or doctor or something, you would not have seen me claiming my role at this point, I would’ve lied
Yeah.
Every good mafia player can fake sensible readlist anyway.
Acting on it is what really matters.
Again, intentions more important than facts.
Pure facts in mafia mean nothing pretty much.
Take that someone claims, it can go either way if you take a sore fact “he claimed”.
What matters is intentions and actions, and how it “flows” the game.
That’s how I see it at least.
If Zorvo W then I look at Silviu and Marl a bit more due to them being as defensive of them as they are. I think Wind’s probably good if Zorvo W because Wind’s back and forth ‘Do I vote? Don’t I vote?’ there feels more legit.
If Zorvo T then honestly I still don’t know too much here rn. I need to see wagon movement for definitive thoughts.
Again, ask if it would remove them from the list of people, as in it would give you 4 people if you targeted upper part, despite there being 8, or if it would just say they don’t visit.
So for example:
8 people
2 of them targeted same person as Conroy
1 targeted someone else
Would the result be 7 or 9?
Yeah
And actually, on a related note I’m back to thinking Memes is town-
He reacted immediately when I claimed, said it was absolutely wolfy, and voted me.
I don’t think a wolf, who knows I’m town, reacts that quickly to call my claim BS or a wolf role. I mean, yeah, maybe a wolf would call it a wolf role but I think reaction speed and how exactly they handle it is a tell, and also I would expect them to test the waters and call it a wolf claim but not vote me right away.
Also
10 players
You target first 5 (you are 9th)
2nd person targets 8th
3rd person targets 1st
Is it 6 or 8?
It’s permanently locked to the numbers on the playerlist so I’m always 11th
Or did you mean hypothetically?
this
That gives 8 assuming no disruptions btw, if you were just giving an example with a playerlist of 10 to begin with
And you cannot just target “Everyone”, can you?
I’m thinking what is the use of this role.
No
It’s guaranteed to be either players 1-9 or 10-18