eh id argue that’s bad enough that its too wolfy to be a wolf, and if we take into account their other reads id say it generally makes sense with what I remember them discussing around that time
Like I think this post is quite towny as much as I want to OMGUS
I also townread them for more complicated reasons than you’re presenting, I just struggle to properly explain most of my reads because their a culmination of many thoughts bouncing around and its hard to keep all those things in mind let alone regurgitate them in a way that’s comprehensible
Unless you telling me why I shouldn’t wolfread them, don’t expect me to drop from their wagon…
He had almost no substantial read D1, so don’t tell me he had so much other reads at that point. (saying I am townreadong this and this players aren’t substantial reads, especially if it copies the towns mentality at that point.)
(Not having read D1 on itself isn’t a sin yet, I usually don’t have them either.)
He challenged one of Zug’s question, which he thought will make him look back. (He cares about apparence, without doing any towny thing so far.)
Derp’s/Brad inactivity and Chomps activity which were his main focus until the Soweli/Ishmael incident. (For him both UTR mentality and active mentality are bad, which is just…)
The rest of his post of D1 is just fluff.
D3 he dropped a readlist without even checking gamestate. (Or pretending that he isn’t care about gamestate)
[I skipped D2, missing out on D2 is understandable, since it really was New Year.]
Tell me, why, where and how should I townread him?
The last time I saw you making this read you used it to townread wolf Kiiruma in that Zone game where Sultan won. I tried to convince you that it was wrong but you wouldn’t budge.
You’re 100% sure our PoE is wrong because we present, in your opinion, no concrete cases and your alternative is Marluna for which you have no concrete case other than “why townread her?”
You have a burning desire for the consensus to be wrong, and for you to be right. You want the wolves to be deep. Inherently. I dont think it matters what reads other people have. I think you would make your contrarian on purpose no matter what. If Marluna was the PoE and nobody wanted go kill Ash, you would be telling us how Marluna is a LHF and we need to kill Ash.
I don’t think this choice of playstyle leads to a higher winrate than playing like how most people do. Even if you are correct that Marluna is mafia you’re telling us nothing. You are scumreading her for a reason you just denounced. You scumread me and Zug earlier because we were the most townread people. I am skeptical at how much you prioritize doing what you think is the most logical thing to help your team win vs how much you prioritize your desire to entertain yourself by maximizing the possibility of you calling out deep wolves so that people are impressed by you post game.
The thoughts theyve made have made sense and shown their actually thinking about the game IMO
can’t really debate that with you its one of those things you kinda either agree with or don’t (or at least I don’t have the ability to properly elaborate on why their thinking make sense with the admittedly small amount of content)
hence why I plan on watching for two days while we kill the POE, its pointless to go against the thread because no one actually wants to change their mind (me included not shade or anything lol)
But…
That’s the point of the game.
If you really think Ash isn’t mafia, at least try to convince me (and others) instead just drop the statement “i disagree you.”
And you probably won’t believe me, but without you prompting me/us (that we had no reason to vote Ash, other than others look better) I wouldn’t have really looked into his posts any deeper, but now I convinced myself, that he is very likely to be mafia.
this is why I’m not bothering to debate it, you’re clearly conf biased regardless of their alignment so even if I was good at putting these thoughts into words I’m 100% confident it still wouldn’t matter rn
Show me any of his thoughts about this game. Anytime I saw an original thought from him D1, he was referencing other games without really any correlation to this game.
Which is just fluff…
last time I did this when someone asked they then ignored it
spookycat27 (3): Leafia, Zugzwang, Chomps
Ash (3): tutuu, Marluna, Creature
Not Voting (3): spookycat27, SirDerpsAlot, Ash
Then don’t work with me, fine.
We will see who was right, if Ash flips.
ill perhaps do it later but I don’t currently have the energy to hard defend them when I’m going against the entire game
their lack of presence doesn’t like motivate me or anything either
Like I would know their alligment, that’s what we are trying to figure out, but so far, his wolfy traits way outnumber their towny traits for me.
And it is way outside of twtbaw cat.
If somebody is that wolfy, it is probably just a wolf.
This is how I used to feel about leaf when I first started playing with them
I think my big thing is what I look for in terms of a wolf/town tends to larley differ from like what the average mafia player does/I put less stock in many things I see a lot of people put a lot of stock into
It really dosen’t help the entire POE is mostly MIA so also can’t realtime anything which is where I think I generally do best as well
That’s really a bummer, I agree on that part.
if im not in thread and Ash/Spooky are online someone @ me and hope the site decides to give me the email notification
stop trying to pocket me >:(
I will try