@Litten you have my interest. Condition 3 hasn’t been immutable in my own mind, although I haven’t heard “the condition”, just the mention of them concealing their claim. I’ll go over it for the sake of theorycrafting.
A team minimally consisting of Bionic / Marluna / Tutuu / +1 could see an evil Shabaloth of any type needing to kill one Minion in order to resurrect another, as an idea to justify the proposed nightkill you’re suggesting. I don’t really know what Tutuu’s claim is, although if they’re claiming Townsfolk!Shabaloth who resurrected Marluna then I should thunderdome them 9/10 times here. Regarding issues.
My whisperlogs don’t show any common denominators between any of the three on the first day, and Marluna’s ability would have to be at least half real to keep Someone initially good. Except they were willing to execute to save themselves on D2, openwolfing in the process which wouldn’t be indicative of an attempt to wolfside in this scenario from the onset. We just had an extra unexplained nightkill for reasons, because it’s not an Arsonist or any other predictable pattern.
Then we’d still have another evil between SDA / Litten / Amelia as the fourth due to the Artist pings and Harpy claim. As the Demon no less. Demon!SDA likely isn’t given Amelia’s name on D1…
Kiiruma’s call for protection on Amelia is an evidently strong argument against Demon!SDA, unless SDA wanted to maintain the livelihood of their pings for longer, or if Kiiruma’s bluffing about it to pressure SDA (plausible). I concede to that point, sure.
