Cookie Thread Act 1: A Cookie in Time

might be?
idk

1 Like

Gorta

Bottom text

The one with angels?

I’ll look into it eventually
finding it takes more than 5 minutes and potentially is frustrating

1 Like

Yeah I think it’s Witch Hunt
Unless you mean town of salen

ok but why is my brain seriously saying that playing around conversion is incredibly skill-testing regardless of CoDs merits

2 Likes

Me when converted into win / loss

it arguably is
it absolutely is

you can certainly get converted into a win or loss but it’s also a unique situation that radically changes information and the mafia gameplay looop

1 Like

Fair

so what is champs optimizing for

“skill testing while maintaining an absolute priority on the basic mafia gameplay loop”

1 Like

tbh I think “conversion is skill-testing” is genuinely true it’s just that a lot of the skills it tests (e.g. reading for conversion) are generally not valued

2 Likes

Like objectively speaking if you compare Chair of Deception and Mountainous the former tests more total skills :joy_cat:

1 Like

that could work
and is representative of mafia as a whole since conversion inherently cannot be an accurate representation of the true basic mafia game

this is true
do you have any thoughts on the question

What should champs test for in terms of player skills?

1 Like

champs should test for toxicity

1 Like

sfol anarchy

1 Like

not even close

1 Like

The more toxic post game is, the better the setup

2 Likes

Getoutofmyhead

1 Like

I don’t understand player skills regarding mafia well enough to make a conclusion on

What should champs test for in terms of player skills?

1 Like