Cookie Thread Act 3: The Cookie Strikes Back

even in homebrew sets the storyteller chooses what amnesiac does. you just never know

there are all-amne games though. and some of them are. awesome!

1 Like

proud of myself for reviewing an album i listened to 3 months ago before 2025 :pray:

1 Like

next time we run an S&Veensy I might try adding Toymaker, I don’t love the dynamic of evils not knowing who each other are

2 Likes

yeah that fucked me. how is evil twin supposed to advance agenda when i don’t know what that agenda is?

2 Likes

hopefully enough people show up so that we never have to run s&veensy again. but i am also LUF’ed out after that game

1 Like

Same.
LUF keeps making me a Leviathan.
I don’t want to be a Leviathan anymore.

1 Like

monkey’s paw curls

Widow: On your first night, look at the Grimoire & choose a player: they are poisoned. 1 good player knows a Widow is in play.

2 Likes

being widow’s fun because you’re the only one who actually knows what’s going on

2 Likes

glad to see it worked out :)

1 Like

it’s fun to hear savant info and in real time figure out which one’s true and which one’s false. too bad the savant was poisoned though :/

2 Likes

The real monkey’s paw would be giving me a Soul Gem.

1 Like

@Ash this is how all-amne games go btw

3 Likes

(intentionally cherry picking an unhinged example for comedic effect)

1 Like

Oh dear god.

this was far far from the most unhinged thing about this game. but i can’t even explain the unhinged parts because i don’t really understand them myself

1 Like

Send them anyways.

there were third party mythics who had various esoteric wincons. that they didn’t know

1 Like

it would take like 20 screenshots to explain just the symphony and i still don’t even entirely know what it means!

1 Like

Like, “Cause the Collision” level of esoteric?