Cookie Thread Act 3: The Cookie Strikes Back

the consequence was that good players didn’t know they got it unless they specifically asked for a wish, while evil players knew everyone got a wish, including themselves

2 Likes

“The town knows how to fully summon every Mythic”

2 Likes

why r u guys such nerdies?

3 Likes

“Trigger every Remember effect in the game”

1 Like

The last one was actually ok tho

If not good design

“Each day, the Ensemble must know more abilities than they knew the previous dusk.”

(Ensemble are just normal players)

1 Like

Most of them are really bad

Like. So fucking bad

The ~only good one off the top of my head was Trouble Bargaining

you claim to enjoy closed setups and yet you don’t enjoy all-amne setups. hypocritical much? :/ :/ :/ :/ :/

3 Likes

Oh also in case you couldn’t tell none of the mythics had agency over whether or not they won (based solely on initial wincon)

No it’s just that clocktower design is very, very hard

1 Like

It’s far easier to make a shit all amnes than a shit closed setup

And it’s already pretty easy to make a shit closed setup

2 Likes

keep in mind the creator of the symphony all-amne game has created multiple purely homebrew scripts that are at least somewhat well respected by the botc community

2 Likes

Most of which are very mechanically solvable

they’re at least the mind behind new world chaos (don’t ask whether it deserves the respect it gets)

2 Likes

Yeah :wowee:

This is, iirc, the guy who said every all amnes script should be 100% solvable

1 Like