oh
logically this feels obvious when you say it
but also I realize how much I have viewed some disabilities as a tragedy now that I read this
this killed me
1 Like
it didn’t ask what I’d pick, it asked what I was morally obligated to pick. it’s possible that if I had a kid I’d make the morally wrong choice of saving my own child and letting ten kids die.
3 Likes
Blindness as A Discrete Badness that happens to other people and can be cured or uncured and which holds some set amount of Negative Moral Value. Or even the opposite perspective of ohhh well it improves your other senses so it’s good actually. It’s not good or bad it just is. Accepting stuff for anything other than “is” is foreign to me
1 Like
yea your morally obligated to pick your child
the people who make these scenarios are psychopaths btw. i feel like it needs to be known
1 Like
99% of the time
Morally obligated? Give me the value of the lives. How brilliant and athletic is each child
1 Like
They are all May
2 MORE
You become aware that a piece of machinery in your workplace is faulty and that if it is not repaired then there will soon be an accident which will result in someone losing the use of their legs. Despite knowing that nobody else is aware of the fault, you take no action. Shortly afterwards, the accident occurs, and someone does lose the use of their legs. Are you morally responsible for their injury?
Responsible
Partly Responsible
Not Responsible
One trillion percent
1 Like
this is definitely covered in a definition of legal culpability
1 Like
Partial
1 Like
How you became aware in the first place?
of course responsible
1 Like
I’m assuming you almost got your legs chopped off.
well there are also laws against committing mass genocide but that doesn’t mean they’re correct
3 Likes
your not the one who’s job it is to make sure its safe
arctic do you realize what you just said
Why would you hide that kind of detail? It could chop your leg the next time…