Cookie Thread Act 4: katze thread

General
#6782

OH wait yeah it also had no nightkills psure. that would explain it

#6783

i dont mind rng ties, each player has agency over it not occuring (unless they are afk for eod). it would suck if ur afk and u cant influence it. but if ur online u have the choice to let it through or not and/or persuade your fellow players to not let it through and back off

#6784

Favour was announced on ties only. The game ended on two consecutive ties. So we knew the last wolf team had a favour of like 3 (lower was better) and were waiting in suspense to see if the Good team they tied with got even luckier

1 Like
#6785

They did not

1 Like
#6786

It’s RNG ties but evil

#6787

the only evil incarnate ties ive seen (or heard rumors, i forgot if i played there or not) was zone’s tie → random player outside tie is executed

2 Likes
#6788

I mean
if you’re online at EOD then you can prevent the tie… by voting the wagon you’re not currently on (which you probably think is townier) :wowee:
you can persuade others but that’s kinda like saying “just find the wolves” imo

#6789

the 2nd most evil is tie → no execution

1 Like
#6790

Yeah I heard about this
it was ran here

#6791

oh ngl I played a mini-setup which had “random town player outside the tie gets executed”
but due to the setup, and that being clearly stated, it was ok

#6792

do you dislike rng ties from an enjoyment or wincon perspective? i agree they’re down low on the enjoyment department. every other solution is siding with the wolves though, except “first to reach tie dies”, that one’s netural

1 Like
#6793

I should make a setup

1 Like
#6794

enjoyment

#6795

some solutions aren’t wolfsiding tho
like if we had the most recently killed player decide ties (who’d usually be the nightkill)

#6796

I like first to reach tie dies because I was a wolf in one and everybody was sooo content to leave things in a tie and let the claimed VT get executed but I went and last minute solo broke the tie to get the unclaimed JOAT executed. Can’t do that with rand ties

2 Likes
#6797

I am making a setup rn thtbhtbthbthbthb :flushed:

#6798

That seems delayful and asking players to keep up with game after they’re killed often ends poorly

1 Like
#6799

What if I made Combinatorics Role Madness

1 Like
#6800

do they make a list or they need to wait and submit? there might be some issues with timezones here in either way. if they make a list, their list might be bad due to missing a claim at eod due to timezones, making a bad tie list. if its the second the wolves would need to wait for them to come online which might take a lot of time

1 Like
#6801

oh
yeah that’s true

though this is the tie resolution that’ll be used in Jail (the delay has been accounted for)