[Game Thread] Morbtainado - Morbfia EPIC win

[Zorvo]

@Magnus

Alright, I’ll drop it for now. I’ll try to catch up on why Squid’s a suspect.

Wouldn’t mind your read on Squid yourself.

[min]

THIS QUOTE FILLS UP MY PHONESCREEN

[min]

I agree tbfh

VOTE: ThePigeonnyc

[min]

This post is kinda towny ngl

[Leafia]

Not too sure why you’re giving me townpoints just for that honestly. Can you please explain? It almost doesn’t sound serious to me.

@min

There’s a post cap?

Yes. Of 150 posts.

Going to give Achro/min a light not w/w read since I feel if both of them were wolves, one of them would’ve reminded the other about the post cap. I have trouble believing that two wolves missed it. It could be an attempt to derpclear them of not being w/w though, so I’m not going to put too much stock into my not w/w read for the teo of them.

@Jaiden

GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD EVENING GENTLEPEOPLE.
To all the people meeting me for the first time, hello there! I am Jaiden, the great deceiver! If you were planning to read me this game, I suggest you stop now. Or don’t. I’ll win either way. If there is one thing I am well known for it is being hard to read and if you ever think you have a lock on me it is SHEER LUCK. For the record, I do plan on using the entirety of the post cap per day. I will be getting the full Morbtainado experience. I have already watched Morbius™ 172 times in preparation for this, using 2 monitors, 2 phones, 2 TVs and a Wii U™ gamepad via a pirated copy of the movie in 180p I found on Reddit™. I am fearless. I am prepared. I am Jaiden. In all honesty, I expected this game to take a while to start, I’m fairly used to delays snowballing given my home communities. It is quite a nice change of pace to have games start on time. Also to note, I have also already adjusted to this site’s customs, and I will be fitting in very, very well. Each and every post I make will be completely serious with just a hint of sass and you will love every second of it. My last game was a fluke on the scum side. While I did have very good reads (as always) putting the scum down to 3 people, I was not able to use my wit and charming personality to sway the votes of the people due to me not knowing Zorvo’s true identity. If I knew who Zorvo was I would’ve immediately gotten them hammered. They would’ve went from most likely scum to lockscum. My reads on them are flawless. You will not be seeing such inaccuracies from me ever again. I will be reading every single post and I will have flawless opinions for every single post. I will be playing at 100% with no drawbacks. No setbacks. No handicaps. I will be causing pure destruction perfectly reading every single scum in the game. Without reading a single post I can tell you who the scum are: thepigeonnyc and Apocryphal. That is just how good I am. Speaking of my Wii U™ gamepad, did you know when I started playing forum mafia I played on just that? A Wii U™ gamepad? If you ever see a post from me anywhere from before late 2019 it was written with a stylus. In my opinion that’s one of the best ways to play mafia. In the old days me and my fellow gentlepeople would play mafia by sending round a notebook via mail. I always won. My handwriting was simply too impeccable to lie against. If I could use my fountain pen in this thread? I would’ve won before the game started. You may of noticed I only have talked about my townplay. That is for one simple reason. I am town, and if I wasn’t town I would still be indistinguishable from town. If you have 2 computers, and on one computer there is a person talking to you live and in the other is a perfect AI replica of that person with memories and all, you have to treat them both like they’re the real person. This is the same as me as scum in mafia. You must treat me as town as to anyone but myself I am town. My mafia play is just that good. As for my other scum tricks, it is for the best I don’t tell you them. Don’t want to give you all ideas that you can defeat me, do I? News flash: You can’t. You have lost and I have won. As for the people I do know in this game, I doubt any of you read any of that. That’s why I put this at the end. So you would see it. I request you stay out my way. That is all. I will now read up on the thread so I will see you all shortly. Thank you. Good day.

First time seeing this copypasta. I officially love it.

@Achromatic

VOTE: Jaiden

And

@Jaiden

@Achromatic @Apocryphal you two have too similar names. Change them. Now.
VOTE: Achromatic

Things just got interesting.

@Jaiden

@Achromatic

I would never consent to a disgusting wall post like that tbh

Disgusting? It is beautiful

This is honestly something I agree with.

@Jaiden

@Achromatic

This feels so overproduced tbh.

You feel really nervous in tone. Are you nervous, Jaiden?

No. I am never nervous. Ever.
This is a good link into doing another wall but I’ve already done one this game it’ll do
my next game will be the fabled 2 walls in a row

You honestly seem pretty relaxed to me. You kind of remind me of Hippo in a way.

@Jaiden

i needed an excuse to OMGUS really badly to see how he’d respond
I don’t really know him yet so idk how to feel about his response but It’s telling of his personality at least
and that’s useful as it gives some information on how he might play

Yeah. I can tell you’re a skilled player already.

@Mistyx

i am so glad i invited you to this site

Me too to be honest.

@Achromatic

My first thought was that if you are wolf it would fit your nature to have your wolf buddies be exactly pigeon and apoc because you feel like the type to do a stunt like that page one and do a dance on town’s grave if you ended up winning the game. As town, I see you looking to repeat past success on Zorvo’s slot by reaction testing early to see if they respond in some way. You feel confident in being able to read them, so baiting them into something is a strategy you wish to employ here to establish an early foot hold. As wolf, you did this Zorvo mention in order to manipulate that slot in other ways. Not sure what you wanted out of Apoc and Pigeon if town here, felt a little too fleeting to read into.

As either alignment you bolstered this with fluff in order to hide intent. It felt purposeful as well as peak dramatic. A post that immediately makes me focus on you much more.

Going to go out on a limb here and say that Achro and Jaiden are somewhat likely to both be villagers. Their interaction just feels like two villagers trying to get a good read on each other to me. It feels pretty natural too.

@Kanave

not a big fan of leafia’s opening stuff tbh, seemed kinda meme-y (which is nai obv) but then got defensive when someone implied they might be wolf cause of it. just not a fan
/vote Leafia @door
also I forgot there was a post cap so imma stop typing like this, anyone else alive? im not going to be here much longer

Not too sure what to think of Kanava’s vote here since they haven’t been the villagwriest before it and something about them felt off, but they at least provide reasoning and I can see how a villager with no experience with me could think that so I’ll put them at null for now.

@Achromatic

Do you have experience with Leafia? I do not have much, so defensiveness from what I have seen when looking up previous games didn’t seem a good indicator of alignment.

Literally their first ever game with me.

@Magnus

Pinging me at 4am in the morning will not wake me any sooner.

Sorry. Didn’t know it was 4 A.M. for you.

@Magnus

Possible logic in worlds where Leafia is Mafia: she’s rolled wolf, she’s feeling nervous. She’s not in the right frame of mind. She’s talking because she doesn’t want to be inactive, and to take the edge off.

Ummm, I’m never nervous as a wolf. Unless I’m under heavy suspicion or things aren’t going my way. I’m also a lot more serious at start of game as a wolf too. I love being wolf.

Magnus’s read on me sucks to be honest. It doesn’t feel real. You aren’t silly like that when you’re nervous and no one is nervous at the beginning of a game because nothing much is happening. I’m perfectly happy with my vote as it stands right now.

@May

Hello, fellow Morbheads. In the same boat as Squid here, but I can at least place a vote.

Leafia’s posts seem strange to me, though I am not experienced in the art of Poasting around here. It feels like it’s intended to throw confusion around - this post I’m replying to creates a weird connection that could mess up anyone retroactively analyzing their behavior after an evil flip. VOTE: Leafia

Yeah. This is a wolfy as f popin.

@Jaiden

ive not played with leafia for over 3 years and I literally wouldn’t expect anything else

I don’t think we’ve ever played together, have we? It’s possible we did on Discord and I’m just not remembering.

@ElizaThePsycho

magnus does feel like he’s grasping for reasons to kill leafia tho

That’s the same feeling that I’m getting honestly.

@Magnus

We can agree villagers and wolves think and post differently, that’s what social deduction works. Stress is a factor in that change. Rolling mafia is immediately more stressful than rolling Town, since the pressure’s on you to lie to the collective brainpower of town. Mafia need to pretend to be Town, and certain players do that better than others. This isn’t a debated opinion, although that doesn’t specifically point to Leafia.

Not everyone feels stress when they roll wolf. Some, like me, even prefer rolling wolf and don’t get stressed about it at all. It’s also a well known fact that I vastly prefer being a wolf.

@Mistyx

on a serious note i have no idea how you think playing mafia is objectively more stressful than playing town

It isn’t.

@thepigeonnyc

Eliza you’re the one grasping for reasons to kill Magnus, I suspect yoy

No. Magnus is the one grasping at straws to kill me and please actually explain your vote instead of just putting one down like that.

@ElizaThePsycho

im not i just think the reasoning is dumb

I have rarely seen dumber reasoning.

@ElizaThePsycho

@ElizaThePsycho

i will admit the tmi-ing self vilager part is wolfy but like

literally said this

Why can’t villagers be silly like that?

I like how solvy Misty is being so far, so very slight townlean on her.

@Zorvo

@May

Hello, fellow Morbheads. In the same boat as Squid here, but I can at least place a vote.

Leafia’s posts seem strange to me, though I am not experienced in the art of Poasting around here. It feels like it’s intended to throw confusion around - this post I’m replying to creates a weird connection that could mess up anyone retroactively analyzing their behavior after an evil flip. VOTE: Leafia

I’m keeping that post in mind for potential partnering if one of you flip wolf.

Not too sure what to think of Zorzo so far, but if he really is Seth, I think he deserves a townpoint or two so far.

@Zorvo

TMI and Agenda is a big thing when catches wolves and finding town.
If there is no TMI or Agenda in a post but you notice allot of genuine thoughts from the player, there is a very high chance that player is town.

This is something I’ve noticed too. Especially late game.

@Mistyx

again, not a true morbhead

everyone knows true morbheads haven’t watched the movie

I had never heard of the flavor before joining the game myself. I just joined because of the gun mechanic.

@Zorvo

I can tell you this much though.

I think Magnus’s vote on Leafia looks way better then Pigeon’s.

I think they’re equally as bad myself.

@Magnus

I think Leafia and Zorvo could either be w/w or t/t, but not w/t.

A bit surprised Magnus didn’t just flat out call Zorvo and I w/w. I guess I can give him a town point or two for that. Still scumleaning him though.

@min

I don’t think it’s inherently wolfy to make a read like that unless they’re ~fairly aware of how leafia acts

Magnus has been in several games with me.

@Zorvo

Leafia ain’t the type to want to look Townie and if you haven’t figured that out yet after playing with them so long, then you shouldn’t be so uptightly confident with something that is inaccurate.

Hi Zorvo. Nice to meet you. Looking villagery is very important to me regardless of my alignment. I have no idea where you get the idea that it isn’t.

Fially got caught up too.

[Mistyx]

@Leafia

Not too sure why you’re giving me townpoints just for that honestly. Can you please explain? It almost doesn’t sound serious to me.

i didn’t say what i was giving you townpoints for???

[Mistyx]

also min i’ll answer you in a little bit i was trying to figure out how to word it and got distracted

[Magnus]

@PoisonedSquid

I didn’t realize the thread opened up hours ago and my brain cells are dead trying to read the posts so far.

Nothing stands to me too much so far since I speedran some post reading, but I’m betting that’ll change as people post more

@PoisonedSquid

I did read it, but my brain is a bit cloudy and I can’t remember most of it. I know it involves analysis of one person’s posts and your greeting, but that’s about it

@Jaiden

I didn’t read a single post at that time
I even stated I didn’t read a single post at that time
Someone sounds like they need to reread my first post.

Squid seems to be mentally exhausted, not originally paying particular attention to the thread.

@thepigeonnyc

Eliza you’re the one grasping for reasons to kill Magnus

@PoisonedSquid

Do you think it’s likely that Eliza and Leafia are part of a wolf team?

I don’t think this interaction necessarily points towards a Pigeon/Squid scumteam. I can understand why the Pigeon suspicions stem from this, although I’m pretty sure Squid could ask this question as either alignment. I’m not analysing the former here. NAI on Squid.

@Mistyx

quick note about the pigeon post i called bad before i gotta go do a thing

the vote on leafia is perfectly fine in context sheeping isnt particularly ai, and there’s no reason to doubt that he actually parsed the case

my issue is with the callout on eliza because thats like

not what was happening

and it feels like a wolfy reach to say it was

@PoisonedSquid

So you’re saying that it could be an attempt to link a scum with a town to potentially lower the pool

Pretty interesting take

I’m pretty sure what Squid means by this is “it could be an attempt to link a scum (Pigeon) with a town (Eliza)”.

@Zorvo

@May

Hello, fellow Morbheads. In the same boat as Squid here, but I can at least place a vote.

Leafia’s posts seem strange to me, though I am not experienced in the art of Poasting around here. It feels like it’s intended to throw confusion around - this post I’m replying to creates a weird connection that could mess up anyone retroactively analyzing their behavior after an evil flip. VOTE: Leafia

I’m keeping that post in mind for potential partnering if one of you flip wolf.

@Zorvo

Might seem NAI but I barely noticed squids post myself so them immediately catching it and using the term “same boat” makes me uneasy.

@May

The boat’s just not having realized the game started and having to backread, but fair. I feel like if I were wolf with Squid, I would specifically be paranoid about acknowledging them and using that sort of wording, but hey, it’s D1.

I really don’t think this points towards May/Squid as a scumteam.

@Zorvo

@PoisonedSquid

Okay yeah, this is just a giant shitpost. Why did my brain assume that it’d lead to big brained scum finding? Hnggh

Dude like….
Who finds scum on their entrance post?

I don’t get how this is suspicious.

If Squid was Mafia, which I don’t currently believe is the case, they won’t be partnered with Pigeon or Zorvo. Partnering with May is unlikely. Could be paired with Mist and/or Eliza, not sure who else.

[Leafia]

Oops. Linked it to the wrong post.

[Mistyx]

it’s mostly just

given what i know about magnus it seems like a genuine solving method especially being applied so freely

[Magnus]

@Mistyx

what i know about magnus

And how do you know what you think you know?
Forgive me if I’m wrong, but I’m pretty sure we haven’t interacted in any recent Mafia matches.

[Mistyx]

nah but we did enough in fotd that i can totally see this being your style

[Magnus]

@Mistyx

leafia too but with conditions that ill explain later

Can you explain this yet?

[Magnus]

@epitau Once you can, it’d be nice to hear your thoughts on everything.

[Mistyx]

imo the best way to read leafia is seeing if her most likely internal worldview lines up with what she’s saying in the thread

which mostly just takes experience with leafia

and so far i would say it is mostly lining up

[Magnus]

In your current worldview, who’s in the scumteam?

[Mistyx]

we are 11 hours into day one slow your roll there

[Magnus]

Fine. In your current worldview, who would you consider reasonable potential suspects?

[Mistyx]

pigeon may achro

zorvo squid min all kinda whatever so far as well

[Zorvo]

@Leafia

Hi Zorvo. Nice to meet you. Looking villagery is very important to me regardless of my alignment. I have no idea where you get the idea that it isn’t.

Dude I could have sworn in a game or two you state you don’t care to look Townie.