GOAT^2 - Game Thread (5/15) - Day 6 - Mafia wonnered

[YoubutWorse]

We dont need to overthink this, we just need to get it done. If magnus flips town then Ill figure shit out from there, but rn theres not a ton of use in detwrmining what to do if magnus flips town/wolf and trying to predict who dies at night and also how someones posting is tomorrow and etc etc. That is something we can leave for tomorrow because we will actually have the information tomorrow

[Lemonfairy]

yessss

[Lemonfairy]

friends, let’s stay calm and not tinfoil paranoia obvtowns

[Lemonfairy]

but I have to give props to May and Magnus for continuing to post and keeping up the act despite being outed
I would’ve lost all WiM and started ATEing

[YoubutWorse]

Lemon can we mason since we killed KT who I masond with before

[Lemonfairy]

yes
let’s be masons

[Host_Account_1]

Magnus (2): Vulgard, YoubutWorse
Lemonfairy (2): Magnus, May
May (1): mollylikesorigami

Not Voting (2): Lemonfairy, BradLand

Day ends 2022-10-04T22:00:00Z

[Lemonfairy]

ok
time to respond to the scumcase Magnus made for me

they spent time making one so of course I need to respond

@Magnus

First of all, pushing Marl apparently wasn’t entirely your idea.

of course it wasn’t
other people had the same idea as me or else Marl wouldn’t have died
I was also 500+ posts behind and making the same conclusions while catching up so quoting my delayed response doesn’t really prove anything?

also, my point was that I did not just “chill in the background” as you have suggested
sure, I was not the first nor the only one to scumcase/push Marl, but I did not take a backseat while others pushed them

@Magnus

That’s how long it took for you to vote anyone, but with the heat on you felt the need to vote someone, so you went after Marl.

again, I was catching up
and I think I made that fairly obvious while doing so

@Magnus

Here’s how long it took for you to justify that read, while deflecting questions about why you hadn’t explained your read yet all the while:

I mean, it took time to make so idk why time is an issue
I deflected answering because my reason was really an amalgamation of everything I saw and it felt like I wouldn’t capture everything if I just gave a shortened and simplified version of it

also you quoting my incorrect scumreads from D2 + me yelling about them proudly in thread is

@Magnus

I was scumread the last two times I wrote up a wolfcase, and accused of looking through a biased lens and justifying myself unreasonably.

maybe try to be more objective?
and cut down on the self-justification

@Magnus

I’m discounting myself, and separating the groups to make it easier for myself.
Given an execution and a nightkill, I’m pretty sure the scumteam is just made obvious.

it just looks like you’re trying to keep your options open for the exe

@Magnus

Don’t sheep Vulgard if I flip Town, please. I don’t trust his current readlist.

you mean the readlist that has me and YBW as town?
I think it looks good

@Magnus

Regardless of your alignment, you shouldn’t be night,ille

unfortunately, I think you might be right on this
looks like scum need me alive to try and misexe me

maybe they’ll reconsider if enough townies TR me

@Magnus

I’m just having a conversation.

and anything you say is said conversation can and will be used against you

@Magnus

Can you quote Min and Eliza’s most recent readlists?

give me a sec
I’ll post this then find them and tag you

@Magnus

In any case, given how nobody other than May seems to be even considering the possibility of me being good

@Magnus

I’ve of the opinion Magnus/May is an agenda push (fmpov), which means May is most likely good here.

I think lemon/Vulgard is an agenda push to take the heat off the designated exes for today and tomorrow (you and May)

@Magnus

Do not vote May out tomorrow.

it’s like you’re trying to anti-anti-spew your partner

@Magnus

I think Lemon’s evil, and their partner is either Vulgard or Brad through process of elimination, much more likely the former.

I think there’s no way town can come to a conclusion like this
your case was also unconvincing

[Lemonfairy]

@Lemonfairy

your case was also unconvincing

I mean, it’d be difficult to convince myself that I’m scum with a scumcase
but my point is that it’s not a good case

[Vulgard]

@Lemonfairy

I think there’s no way town can come to a conclusion like this

That’s the main thing here, these conclusions are just completely unbelievable to me from town on both of their accounts. The KT case earlier was also nonsensical and purely paranoia-driven, there wasn’t even an actual case against him.

[Vulgard]

@Lemonfairy @mollylikesorigami @BradLand Don’t forget to vote.

[Lemonfairy]

@Magnus

here’s min:

@min

VOTE: Magnus

@min

poe: eliza/magnus

and here’s Eliza:

@ElizaThePsycho

VOTE: Magnus

self-pres

@ElizaThePsycho

Molly is townie from the 10 posts I read
YBW should be looked into

@ElizaThePsycho

Vul should be looked into too

I actually misremembered Eliza’s legacy (sorry )
Eliza actually wanted Vul and YBW

[Lemonfairy]

Magnus (2): Vulgard, YoubutWorse
Lemonfairy (2): Magnus, May
May (1): mollylikesorigami

Not Voting (2): Lemonfairy, BradLand

[Vulgard]

Lemon if you’re actually mafia then I don’t think I’ve ever been pocketed any harder than this.

[Lemonfairy]

remember to vote Magnus

I think we’re fine because both Magnus and May are already on me
so chances of scum quick-voting me are not high

[Lemonfairy]

lol I’m not mafia this time

I don’t think I’d be able to play as freely as I did this game if I were scum

[YoubutWorse]

@Lemonfairy

@Magnus

I think Lemon’s evil, and their partner is either Vulgard or Brad through process of elimination, much more likely the former.

I think there’s no way town can come to a conclusion like this
your case was also unconvincing

Thats the main thing that gets me as well

Vulgard evil, with brad? Maybe. Brad evil, with vulgard? I can believe it. You evil with either of them? There’s no way that’s a genuine thought, it is a last-ditch effort to try and pull heat away.

[Lemonfairy]

@Magnus

Which means it pretty much has to be between Vulgard/Lemon/Molly, and I think Molly’s unlikely to flip wolf.

haha

@Magnus

In any case, kill Lemon always.

hahaha

@May

I have to be right about this Lemon/Vulgard world, and I have to convince every townie about it

hahahaha

@May

I should check on YBW’s iso, just in case, because I think that’s the one we’re most likely to be wrong on, if anyone.

hahahahaha

[Lemonfairy]

@May

Either way, you’ve put in the work today, Magnus, when you could’ve just accepted death lying down, and that’s a point in my book. Multiple points, even. Thanks for playing the mafia game with me when nobody else would.

@Magnus

I’ll look forward to games with you in the future.

this is wholesome
you guys did well (even as scum)

[Lemonfairy]

@BradLand

I hate that Magnus doing all of that work makes him towny.

Why does he have to be towny?

@BradLand

I know I’m losing confidence in it as well but I don’t want to not yeet him today because it was on my mind most of the game but now he’s being towny and I don’t like it I’m just gonna go lay down.

stay strong, Brad