well I initially voted them because Wind was not being townie, and normally she is very townie as town and I didn’t like how Wind was like ‘well I’m not going to try to be villagery’ which isn’t really how she normally plays and some of her reasoning made no sense in a way that sounded fake and also I thought them freezing up after Engineer claimed vig was kind of yikes, like they were a wolf who didn’t know how to react once their designated misexe had been taken away from them
and then once I started pushing them they responded by ATEing and being all like ‘why isn’t anyone listening to me!!’ rather than literally anything else, even though their only actual focus at that point was on the vig claim which didn’t really make sense, and then when I kept pressing them she OMGUS’d and then went back to ATEing
none of which made me particularly inclined to not vote her
also she was basically dead center in the overlap between my PoE and orange’s PoE, which otherwise had some Noticeable Disagreements
-Arete