i am back to do this before i go to sleep
@thethethe
this is my ultimatum
firstly i ask you not to shoot until tomorrow and instead use the option to pre-submit for the deadline so we maximise our time for discussion
i strongly do not think you should shoot cheese90. i think there are actively worse slots than them and the reasons to scumread them are all things i can plausibly see coming from a villager being misunderstood.
please consider shooting sonic. you were in higurashi and saw how obviously town dota was. you were in railgun and saw how lol was playing there. both took the initiative and tried to move the game somewhere. their play in this game is a complete 180 in terms of both of these things and i really think they are the easiest wolf
seth is my next preferred shot. the way he handled your slot, defending your playstyle without actually commenting on your alignment is exactly how wolf seth handles your slot when it’s in contention for being shot. they are also pushing on me for nonsensical reasons, as well as my top town (HH - which contains a head who i have never misread in my 1.5 years playing this game)
the common thing about both these slots is that they have no team dynamic going on behind the scenes like a villager slot would have. all they have commented on about their chats is that their other head agrees with their reads. this isn’t natural - villagers would have points of disagreement and nuance, and as HH pointed out earlier i’d go so far as to say it’s particularly uncharacteristic for seth, someone known to be loud and opinionated, to be this agreeable
i wouldn’t shoot SoS today, but i do think this slot is also a wolf. it contains a head who, in their past 2-3 village games, has either made themselves the most obvious villager in the game or blatantly spewed themselves as a villager. this game they have done neither. their other head is just as unimpressive and has, fmpov, shown hints of agenda on multiple occasions wrt to the early treatment of your slot, cheese’s slot, and treatment of seth’s slot
the next slot that i think is mafia is 2w1h but i don’t think they should be shot today. i can’t really elaborate on it much but the main reasons stem from uncharacteristic emotional behaviour. kiiruma made the most on the chin “everything is great” post just after BBB shot you, someone they townread. this is extremely uncharacteristic for kiiruma, someone known to repeatedly show the most over-the-top unwarranted emotive posts. and here there was just nothing. why? because they were happy with the gamestate. why would a villager who just had their townread shot be happy with the gamestate? not to mention, their townread of you came virtually out of thin air and was still basically never justified
no one is making waves or trying to challenge your shot of me or cheese, except for me. this means that wolves are either happy with the gamestate and we are villagers, or we are w/w. if you think we are w/w then i ask that you shoot us instead because i do not trust the cheese slot with the gun
good night
-gold