Knight-Errant - A Normal Game Mafia Wins!

[otterpopd]

@Achromatic

What is null about Rhea iyo?

i havent read their one post yet

[otterpopd]

it was long and it’s 1am

[Brakuren]

@otterpopd

good response to my rvs

you litterally never interacted with them i just checked

[Achromatic]

that makes sense, sure

[Achromatic]

also its 1am holy shit I am too old for this

[Achromatic]

town friends

Wisp/Milli
Rhea
Brak
Sultan
Kiiruma

gn

[otterpopd]

@otterpopd

people should talk and have thiughts. cor instance my thoughts is that i want to kill hazard VOTE: hazard

@Hazardwaste

exactly otter gets it

not defensive no omgus it was a good response

[Bionic]

honk shoo honk mimimi

[Bionic]

(I’m not calling the game dead i’m just going to sleep gn everyone)

[Someone]

gn, and same

[Frostwolf103]

@Leafia

Why do you believe it so easily?

Yeah. Derps probably town at this point. This isthe type of stuff I’d expect to see from v!Derps.

@Leafia

@Achromatic

Whoever Derps calls town the most we’re cfding them at eod.

Wolfy opener.

Must be wolfy buddy who sees Derps is pressured, oh no.

@Achromatic

Whoever Derps calls town the most we’re cfding them at eod.

@SirDerpsAlot

Reads:

locktown:
Achro

Null:
everyone else

@Achromatic

Town has a 100% win rate when they chop me as town, the numbers speak for themselves.

@SirDerpsAlot

Achro locktown fr tho ez

Charming, but I am not taking my vote off this way.

@Bionic

d1 citizen claim

@Bionic

VOTE: SirDerps

Yeah whatever, NAI.

@Brakuren

Lolchat = people talking to talk rather then to actually solve

@Rhea

Awkward on both sides of the equation. Claiming an N0 redcheck when no such possibility exists in the setup is not something most, if not all, town players would genuinely believe to work, and so it comes across as that kind of opener-for-the-sake-of-an-opener which wolves so love.

SirDerpsAlot didn’t made a reply until I came along, possibly lurking and that prompted him to talk. I am not letting this vote go so easily.

@Rhea

@SirDerpsAlot

Vaugley but Its I think better to leave it at this untill a little later

@SirDerpsAlot

its not a reaction test entirely I do have an actual reasoning

Intentionally hiding information is towny.

@Rhea

@SirDerpsAlot

Reads:

locktown:
Achro

Null:
everyone else

Immediately reacting to an opener in this strong a way is towny.

@Rhea No offense, but can you describe if you actually read the posts you’re meant to read? All I see is putting bunch of ‘town this, town that’ that doesn’t point it out. I am starting to think you’re defending SDA.

@SultanOfSlam

Very weird opening and like others have asked uhh why?

What I am doing is for me to know.

@Bionic

@Frostwolf103 @Hazardwaste @Brakuren yo you all got called wolf by rhea, you all should like, vote them or something

I wouldn’t call them wolf just yet, Rhea is untested waters for me. I have seen the vote on Brakuren which he want to be serious this game, I haven’t seen the exact reasoning from Rhea’s vote not the way I could have understand.

@Brakuren

@Rhea

My strongest wolfread at the moment is Brakuren, as he’s now provided five separate wolfreads or indications of suspicion on posts with only one even slight townlean involved, and it’s on a player who I think was really not all that towny, just formal. His posts reads like a wolf fishing around for suspicion, and often push people for what I feel are surface-level reasons, thinking of the game of mafia as “easy” in a way that wolves tend to do in order to push agenda.

Um?

I only wolf read 2 people?

@Rhea

You quoted and expressed a wolfread on posts from SirDerpsALot, Hazardwaste, Millium, Leafia, and Kiiruma. You have only expressed a townread on Zugzwang, and you have not even expressed the source of that townread.

Actually, I will inquire on that now: why do you townread Zugzwang specifically, and are there any other players you currently think are towny?

@Brakuren

@Zugzwang

This unpairs Hazard and Derps. If they were w/w, Hazard would realistically by giving guidance on how to respond, which is unlikely to have happened given how Derp’s responses were pretty bad (especially the last one here).

I mean it feels like theatre tbh? I don’t really like Derp’s interactions but Ima gonna read their previous games and get back to you

@Brakuren You found you’re looking for?

[Frostwolf103]

@Achromatic

oh boy we’re going to need some translators huh

Pretty much.

[Frostwolf103]

@Kiiruma

I think Rhea is town or 3P.
I don’t think Rhea is groupscum who’s went for such a big post and an attention grab especially since it can backfire (and it did)

@Millium

Gratz on rolling town lol

@Achromatic

I almost think a 3p wouldnt just go for it either tbh

@Kiiruma

I know right? It’s been a while since I’ve been able to roll town and then do good things

I am on Achro on this, that doesn’t necessarily make Rhea town, just NAI from your post.

[Frostwolf103]

@SultanOfSlam

Very weird opening and like others have asked uhh why?

I dissect the post for you

I locktown you, I also lockscum Derps.

[Leafia]

Yes I do. It’s a habit of mine since it doesn’t feel right to me if I don’t do it and couldn’t sleep.

@Crescent

SDA almost immediately “mechanically confirmed” a scum in the previous game for what turned out to be absolutely no reason, and basically torpedoed the town in the process.

Anyways I’m finally home it is time to unite the kittens.

Was he town or a wolf? Wait. I think I know what game you’re talking about and I was the cohost for it. He was town.

@Bionic

we should lynch marluna day one for their crimes

Interesting. Guessing this isn’t serious though.

@Rhea

@Hazardwaste

ight i dont think thats a townie response in the slightest but go get em.

i am making sure it is a joke. cause you never know if frost just tricked the fuck out of wolf @Millium

@Hazardwaste

started beginning of last year.

How good am i? Awful

These are wolfy posts.

@SirDerpsAlot

Vaugley but Its I think better to leave it at this untill a little later

@SirDerpsAlot

its not a reaction test entirely I do have an actual reasoning

Intentionally hiding information is towny.

Please explain Rhea.

@Rhea

Immediately reacting to an opener in this strong a way is towny.

Please explain this too.

@Bionic

@Frostwolf103 @Hazardwaste @Brakuren yo you all got called wolf by rhea, you all should like, vote them or something

Extremely scummy post by Bionic here.

@Crescent

Also to add more to it, based on the way Sultan voted, Bionic and Sultan are almost certainly not paired.

Disagree. I haven’t seen anything unpairing them.

@SultanOfSlam

Your reada litterally have no reason to them and you are also hypocritical. Look like you dont like
Brak beacuse you do not agree with them. Dont like me beacuse of being playful in an opener and joking around this site apparently doesn’t joke around in opening posts.

And the rest of your list is try harding its basically a wlal of word vomit soo…

I have trouble seeing a villager ever making a post like this.

Willing to give Rhea a townlean for now while Achro gets a scumlean. Usually he’s putting in more effort by now when town.

@Kiiruma

Don’t try and read me, I’m just a little ‘no-poster’ uwu

This honestly made me laugh IRL. Laughs

@Brakuren

@Kiiruma

I would agree but the 3P looking like they’re trying to solve provides a level of security for town agreeing with them living long term.

This is nonsense.

3P doesn’t want attention

3P does want to be townread though and would love the good kind of attention.

@Achromatic

this is reminding me a lot of your scum game.

Someone doesn’t remember how Derps was in almost every towngame of his.

@SultanOfSlam

Okay this is great and exactly what i was looking for.
UNVOTE

For now.

Admittedly the first villagery post from SultanOfSlam.

@Millium

anyways going to sleep

Good night.

@Frostwolf103

@SultanOfSlam

Very weird opening and like others have asked uhh why?

I dissect the post for you

I locktown you, I also lockscum Derps.

If Sultan actually is town, I’d say this has a high chance of being TMI that Sultan is town unless Frost can explain his reasoning for locktowning Sultan adequately.

[Leafia]

I guess everyone else is gone at the moment, so good night again everyone.

[Eddie]

SirDerpsAlot (3): Frostwolf103, Achromatic, Rhea
Crescent (3): Kiiruma, SirDerpsAlot, Bionic
SultanOfSlam (2): otterpopd, Leafia
Bionic (1): Marluna
Brakuren (1): Millium
Millium (1): Brakuren

Not Voting (7): ElizaThePsycho, Someone, Hazardwaste, Crescent, Dec, Zugzwang, SultanOfSlam

[Zugzwang]

@Rhea

I like Zugzwang. Not necessarily in an in-game sense. I don’t think this post is unfakeable, as formality is an easy disguise for wolves, and I don’t entirely agree that the interaction unpairs Hazardwaste and SirDerpsALot, as it felt like there was an artificiality to it that could potentially indicate it being faked. But I enjoy his playstyle.

We’ve wolfed together in Zone’s Testament, fwiw. Actually, your play there is part of why I’m trying out this playstyle now.

I’d call your analysis so far towny, as many wolves would struggle to fake that amount of solving, but having seen your wolfgame I’m not so sure :)

[Zugzwang]

Comparing Bionic here to him in Popcorny Redux (town) and in Popcorn3 (wolf), it’s hard to find differences. In Popcorny Redux, he did eventually try to solve though.

---

Posts

@Bionic

actually i hate wall of texts even more

@Bionic

VOTE: Rhea

@Bionic

everyone should vote rhea fr

@Bionic

@Frostwolf103 @Hazardwaste @Brakuren yo you all got called wolf by rhea, you all should like, vote them or something

This sequence is wolfy. Given his reason to vote Rhea isn’t alignment indicative, him pinging 3 people asking them to vote her feels like pushing agenda.

---

@Bionic

honk shoo honk mimimi

@Bionic

(I’m not calling the game dead i’m just going to sleep gn everyone)

These posts are interesting. The first of them was made at 1:21 EST. His previous post was made at 12:24 EST.
In my experience, people announce they’re leaving thread if they were previously actively there - which Bionic was not, unless he was lurking. Lurking isn’t necessarily scum indicative; I do it somewhat frequently as town. However, since Bionic doesn’t seem to be making any reads, I don’t see what t!him would get out of lurking. @Bionic, could you explain this?

[Zugzwang]

@Brakuren

I mean it feels like theatre tbh? I don’t really like Derp’s interactions but Ima gonna read their previous games and get back to you

Why does it feel like theater? To me, Hazard’s responses felt like he genuinely thought Derps may have slipped up.
Also this thought from Hazard is >>rand town, since if Derps is actually town, w!Hazard is more likely to understand it’s just a joke, and I still don’t feel they’re paired.