That would be correct, but unlikely for starting Unseen to be The Sage. Samarie could be starting Cult though.
EhâŚFair enough
Unlikely doesnât mean impossible but I will agree that starting cult is looking more likely.
1 Like
You mentioned you had other reasons to suspect me? What were those reasons?
other statements that pinged me as weird but only if I looked at you in a negative light kind of way. You can say that about anyone though and I think Iâd be right in saying itâs likely unreasonable
1 Like
im kinda at the point where, âIf im immune evil, what can I possibly beâ, as like this big gotcha, just destroyed your whole arguement, should die
I still dont think they are outted
and the whole, âEvils dont want her deadâ, is a bs argument that a lot of the time leads to bad flips, because one, who are these evils? If Samarie is truly outted, I think wolves would just bus here, or cult I guess, its a bit finiky if u start thinking about two evil factions, kinda makes gamestate reads very hard
1 Like
my question is, how can it all be waived away?
also I think evils will most of the time, take w/e push they can get away with, but like same question, but reverse, who are these evils that want them dead?
as more time goes on I get more solidifed in my scumread of Kalev (this has nothing to do with his new posts and everything to do with confbias)
1 Like
The mechanics are confusing enough in a game like this that people might think they have something when they donât. But I still want to flip samarie anyway just to clear the air
1 Like
i mean sure, but usually when someone says something can be hand waived, they have evidence for that, not just a generic statement, that dismantles the arguement, as if one is actually has the evidence to prove it, when they dont
like I can say, âI dont understand why mechanics have led to people believing they are outtedâ, but im certainly not going to say, âThe mechanics dont actually make them wolfyâ, especially when I dont understand the mechanics, and here you clearly stated also that they are confusing
I think Evils want them dead, is just as bad as saying evils dont want them dead, when u canât define who these people are
Honestly I still think Karin should die because they reason for voting Samarie, is abysmal, not in like a haha trolly way, but actually god awful, in a wolfy way
whats ur current read on Karin?
I agree with the line of thinking they have though in that the ability usage seems tame and untrackable compared to anything else that was possible to choose. It would be suspicious on itâs own but with other things too a vote is reasonable from Karin.
Null leaning townread, depending on the allignment of samarie theyâre chasing after this kill without really thinking about much else other than their vote reason imho. If samarie is town I donât like that, if theyâre scum thenâŚI guess it wouldnât really change much for Karin. Bussing would be a thing here after all and we are assuming that Samarie is very caught if they are a wolf.
i dont hate that line of thought since ya, I meant their original read their
this post, still pings the hell out of me
What exactly bothers you about this because on the surface here it looks fine to me. 'Cept maybe the part where they confidently declare they are exactly CL/MM. Too specific for my tastes and an evil version of the CW wouldnât be claiming exactly what they did anyway because uhâŚtheyâd possibly be choosing Unseen/Cult abilities, and claiming that is an insta-out.
the whole âexcitedâ part of their arguement, just doesnt feel real to me
i think the one thing coming out of that that i think is townie, is their CC
1 Like
Maybe a bit of an overexplanation instead of just CCâing but I donât think itâs too far out of left field overall
The Counter Claim depends on the level of knowledge Karin has about the game.
For someone who did not know it would grant more credibility, but it is easily faked for someone who does know the game.