Purgatory - Town Win!

[PrincessAbigail]

@guavagudetama

TOWN
Doleful
Caitlin
Psyx
Luka
Abbi
(purposeful gap)
Ritsu
(another purposeful gap)
tutuu
Merpy
SCUM

Me being this low is a SIN

[PrincessAbigail]

Shame!

[MerpyDerpy]

I’ll look at this after I finish my reads

[Luka]

@MerpyDerpy

I’ll look at this after I finish my reads

Thanks, reads are useful for pairing reasons so take your time

[tutuu]

I didn’t particularly pay close attention.

I do like your bravado! I find it rare to see wolves pushing villagers like that.

[DolefulDetective]

Side note, and not related here as I dont have much to add to the argument in its current state, but just logged in to my computer and im never using the mobile app again… but I lose my emoticons on my computer T^T

[Luka]

@tutuu

I do like your correctness! I find it rare to see wolves pushing wolves like that.

Fixed your post for you

[PrincessAbigail]

@tutuu

I can bring the information that wolves didn’t choose to go for the “hardbus from early on” strategy.

Before I received my alignment, I had considered, if I were to rand Mafia, to agree that 2 of us should bus the third one, as we would need 2 wolves in heaven to win, and given that there’s no NK, being towny is all you need to win.

However, I know that I am town, and I am the top wagon from early on. So I know they decided not to do that. Although, they might decide to, later.

I would be very cautious about bussers. If we receive a wolf flip - please be cautious with sending people to heaven from among the voters.

Why would you like openly state this in thread like giving them either info or taking away a means you could have had to catch wolfs if they did do this…

[PrincessAbigail]

@guavagudetama

so true Doleful

I’m gonna exclusively sheep my town reads

[DolefulDetective]

[PrincessAbigail]

@tutuu

By the way, my wonderful friends, may I ask of you to please share your Battle Themes?

BABYMETAL - メタり！！ (feat. Tom Morello) (OFFICIAL)

[PrincessAbigail]

Mine is the best and I demand credit for having easily the best battle theme here

[Luka]

Abbi am I town

[tutuu]

I am a good Samaritan Townsperson and I believe in transparency and honesty. I have nothing to hide. :3

[MerpyDerpy]

Hell Phase Read 1: Princess Abigail

Princess Abigail: Null/Scum-Leaning

Reasoning

@PrincessAbigail

@guavagudetama

I’ve been in two games with Luka and both times he was scum

lightning always strikes in the same place every time

True. No risks send Luka straight to hell!

They seem supportive of voting Luka over. This early on, however, I don’t think it right to declare them as unaligned. Especially since there was no sign of Luka going over this early on.

@PrincessAbigail

VOTE: Caitlin

Send her straight to Heaven.

Also, confused by this vote. Again, isn’t this current vote to send people to Hell?

@PrincessAbigail

If hell phase is tomorrow than today is in fact heaven no?

Is this confusion an act to get a universal town-read person out? I don’t know if this is in Princess Abigail’s personality or not to do this or not, but it’s worth considering the possibility that this was intentional and wolfy.

@PrincessAbigail

Yeah everyone should vote her I am 1000% sure she’s town.

I haven’t been this confident on a Caitlin read in…9.7 years.

PrincessAbigail town reads Caitlin hard. I am keeping this here to refer back to late game.

@PrincessAbigail

@DolefulDetective

Omg satania!! I love her ｡ﾟ(ﾟ´ω`ﾟ)ﾟ｡

Pocket achieved.

She wants to pocket Dole. Again, not alignment indicative. However, it will likely be a handy tool for later.

@PrincessAbigail

That was my attempt to claim wolf as a joke but now it just looks like I want you to town read me.

@Caitlin

How does that tell you that Merpy wants to townread you? Merpy just says they won’t lock scum you for it

Not being lock scum =/= being townread?

I don’t have anything to add to this, but I don’t want to be accused of avoiding certain statements (especially if they involve me). I do agree with Caitlin’s explanation though. However, I understand Abigail’s confusion. Sometimes, messages online can be difficult to interpret.

@PrincessAbigail

This feels like such a weak reason to town read Cait. She did way better things than this later on.

Unless I missed something, this and her Cait townread are the only reads that Abigail have had so far.

@PrincessAbigail

Me being this low is a SIN

No elaboration on this does feel a bit odd. If Abigail was town and felt like they should be higher on the list, why wouldn’t they explain why? I’m not saying Abigail has to write an essay defending themselves, but I am surprised that it wasn’t called out at all in a non-joking way. It feels like Abigail subconsciously knows the low read is right, so she just took the hit and didn’t defend. That’s just my interpretation though. Again, this plays into my suspicion of lack of communication/transparency. In summary, they are teetering between null (not having a lot of reads atm; mainly rule interpretations) and scum-lean (weird interaction to an accusation).

[PrincessAbigail]

@MerpyDerpy

Thank you for being open about your self-reflection. I wish you the best of luck in pursuing this goal! It is a good mindset to have

I see that Merpy is still being Merpy and I will be hard pocketed by her pureness… cool

[guavagudetama]

@Luka

Not a massive fan of taking that seriously or even suggest NLing. NL here is kinda always suboptimal.

boring

@Luka

@MerpyDerpy

I don’t understand what u mean by this. Are you saying it’s necessary for town to keep you alive for some reason?

Another weird post, given of course if a townie was sent(dont accuse me of TMI) that would lower it. Making content w/o making content.

Psyx didn’t explain that until a later post

@Luka

@MerpyDerpy

All good. I just want to make sure town discusses their reads. Even if you end up scum-reading me, I still want town to talk about your reads with you, so we can solidify them more. (This applies to all of town)

Weird post when you havent given a single read this thread.

gagged

@MerpyDerpy

He tries to get Caitlin to vouch for him early on, but he gets shut down. Yes, I know this isn’t a direct vouch, but claiming that someone can town-read you on D1 feels like you’re planting a seed in the back of someone’s head that you’re town. If Caitlin starts to scum-read Luka, he may bring this up and even use it as ammo to fire back at her. Although this vouch claim did not work, it was still attempted. It doesn’t feel townie to me tbh. Especially given the nature of this game specifically is for wolves to look as townie as possible.

wait that’s so embarrassing
Luka: Caitlin has a 100% readrate on me
Caitlin: I just always say you’re scum though
Luika scum points going up

@Luka

@Caitlin

Town

Cait has only done these types of readlists as scum iirc. Funny post.
Other than that the post gives me a townie ping. Wary of cait tho. Very wary.

oh this is an awful post
VOTE: Luka
“this post is something she only does as scum but it’s also townie” no what
it feels like you’re trying to shade Caitlin while simultaneously pocketing her
Luka scum points SKY ROCK ET ING

@Luka

@Caitlin

Explain, Luka?

If merpy is scum I want eyes on cait

continues to not explain
scum points up
like I know you made that wall on Merpy but.

@Luka

@MerpyDerpy

votes you

Very petty first statement but why not actually vote them here? I don’t see anything wrong with that given its your first post in this game. Petty but regardles

obviously nai

@Luka

@MerpyDerpy

I had a similar proposition in a different mafia game I was in. If we sleep vote, we have a 0% chance of hitting a wolf. If we vote someone, we at least have a chance of hitting a wolf. Idk the math specifically bc I wasn’t the one who did it, but yeee. Maybe our strategy will be different because the heaven and hell system, but it’s worth noting different approaches.

Not a massive fan of taking that seriously or even suggest NLing. NL here is kinda always suboptimal.

if it’s really that suboptimal I don’t think Merpy pushes it as wolf

@Luka

@MerpyDerpy

I don’t understand what u mean by this. Are you saying it’s necessary for town to keep you alive for some reason?

Another weird post, given of course if a townie was sent(dont accuse me of TMI) that would lower it. Making content w/o making content.

jumping her for not being able to see through Psyx’s eyes

@Luka

@MerpyDerpy

Well, of course everyone is going to claim they’re townie. They just made it sound like they were a necessity to be kept alive. Like a mayor or a town power role or something.

Bit hesitant on this but I dont love the post. If they as a town member got a vanilla role, it isn’t a large assumption to say that its all vanilla roles, especially since this is a vanilla setup.
At the same time this post is also townie, since I think scum would pay more attention to the setup
So basically im hedging my bets
Id say this post leans towards town though TwT

jumping her for not reading OP

@Luka

@MerpyDerpy

Right, but at least in mountainous, there was like a whole day of discussion and then a vote typically happens toward the end. Am I misunderstanding?

No, votes happen pretty much always. Whoever dies happens towards the end.
Please vote whom you think is evil.

this was fine actually but this also isn’t sus on her

@Luka

@MerpyDerpy

All good. I just want to make sure town discusses their reads. Even if you end up scum-reading me, I still want town to talk about your reads with you, so we can solidify them more. (This applies to all of town)

Weird post when you havent given a single read this thread.

shading her (even though I laughed you ate her up here)

@Luka

@MerpyDerpy

All good. I’ll be honest: I haven’t thought about town-reading ppl yet. I like to wait for more content to work with. In other words, I like ppl to get the early-game silliness out of their system, so I have more content to work with.

Alot of the content at this point was AI. All the early game silliness has far evaporated. So weird post pretty much.

this was a good point I think
but it might just look good because it’s next to whatever the rest of this wall was

@Luka

Alot of posts just gave me townie pings I couldnt explain. Despite this though, with specifically there content, I’ll put them scum lean.

???
this still feels like trying to make other people suspect her while also trying to pocket her
you can’t do both

@Luka

Not going to address this. Its a silly read and I dont think its worth addressing.

LOLLLLLL

@Luka

I am back to thinking the scum team is Cait + Merpy +1 fwiw

oo! let’s ParticleMan this! Put me in, Coach!

@Ritsu

Am wiped from all social interaction from thanksgiving so amma skim what’s posted and reread later and/or in the morning though seems like alot of stuff being done which is good regardless

Canadian.
I’m onto you.

@Luka

ye we already have an outed evil its great

you?

@PrincessAbigail

@guavagudetama

VOTE: tutuu

I am legally obligated to state that exactly one of these 4 names is a wolf

tutuu (3): Luka, PrincessAbigail, guavagudetama

LOL
based rule of 3 or whatever
and it aligns with
wait no it doesn’t
hm
thinks
you’re town
does that mean tutuu is town
wtf is tutuu doing

@DolefulDetective

Gotcha! I immediately thought of w/w in the way! That makes more sense in this context

ate

@PrincessAbigail

Can you attempt to explain the difference?

off the top of my head I have no clue
I would have to read strat15 again

HEY ME COME BACK TO THIS

I’ll probably see that later

@PrincessAbigail

Me being this low is a SIN

well someone just went below you but also that top 5 was really just in the order I thought to write them down LOL
you were all at about the same level for me until I read Luka’s more recent posts

@PrincessAbigail

I’m gonna exclusively sheep my town reads

well you’re town (praying) so that’s fine

[PrincessAbigail]

@Luka

Weird post at the start of the game. It’s 50 posts in, we don’t have a good idea of this. It doesn’t bring thread progression either.

I haven’t read a damn thing about the set up but this is clearly a joke because there is no night kill right?

[PrincessAbigail]

@Luka

Wolves are more cautious to allign with there town game.

Are they?

[PrincessAbigail]

@tutuu

Great post to townread me for. :-)

You make it very hard for me to not be paranoid of you Tutuu

UNVOTE

This scares me because I was actually like oh that is actually towny but than you said it which means you know it’s towny which means you could just be saying it to get town read.

But… fuck it.