Purgatory - Town Win!

[Caitlin]

guavagudetama (3): DolefulDetective, tutuu, PrincessAbigail
tutuu (2): Caitlin, guavagudetama
Luka (1): MerpyDerpy
MerpyDerpy (1): Luka

Not Voting (2): Psyx, Ritsu

I do wonder why @Psyx and @Ritsu still aren’t voting

[MerpyDerpy]

I trust Tutuu more than I do Arturo here, so I don’t think I will be voting to save Arturo. If a swing vote happens though, I may hop on it depending on who it is.

[Caitlin]

Guava’s focus on the pairing being TvS feels kinda like ill intend to me but I also dont think Luka/Merpy has to be TvT and only if its TvT it rlly is sus

I also feel like Tutuu is more likely a wolf anyway so I’ma keep my vote on Tutuu

But I’m starting to become wary again of Merpy

Doleful is still my top TR; easily right now

[Caitlin]

I gtg bye

[Psyx]

I’m here; just got off work

(24 hours on a Monday is pure hell jfc)

[MerpyDerpy]

@Caitlin

Why would Guava vote on ppl they are 50% sure on rather then ppl they are 100% sure on

I didn’t really think about it this way tbh. I’m not much of a math person. I just took it as they knew their was an evil between us. Ritsu and Tutuu are just the results of POE which, in my personal opinion, does leave room for error if you misclear at least one person. That’s why I was curious on their thought process. To clarify, I am not bashing Arturo’s way of thinking. It is totally valid. I was just curious on their thoughts about the T/W. Hopefully, that helps clear up my thoughts.

[MerpyDerpy]

It’s possible that Ritsu doesn’t know the EOD time. I know I wasn’t quite sure on the time.

[Psyx]

Don’t think I can finish backreading in 30min, can somebody please give a TL;DR for the wagons?

[guavagudetama]

@Caitlin

Guava’s focus on the pairing being TvS feels kinda like ill intend to me but I also dont think Luka/Merpy has to be TvT and only if its TvT it rlly is sus

If Luka/Merpy is t/t I’m misclearing someone

@MerpyDerpy

I just took it as they knew their was an evil between us.

For my world view to make sense with my four townreads, at least one of you had to be evil, and I doubt both of you are evil unless you guys just decided to fight for no reason
Like I refuse to believe Luka/Merpy was planned even if they’re both wolves that was raw

@MerpyDerpy

Ritsu and Tutuu are just the results of POE which, in my personal opinion, does leave room for error if you misclear at least one person.

I understand that I could be misclearing someone
I hope you understand this looks like you defending your scummates rn

[guavagudetama]

@Psyx

Don’t think I can finish backreading in 30min, can somebody please give a TL;DR for the wagons?

I don’t remember why people are voting me or why Caitlin is voting tutuu

I can tell you that I think you/Caitlin/Abbi/Doleful is pure which leaves Luka/Merpy who are obv not w/w and Ritsu and tutuu
So I voted tutuu and if I live I’ll probably vote Ritsu d3
Unless we cfd Ritsu for some reason

[guavagudetama]

@DolefulDetective

Guava is maybe the one person I am a bit worried about. Im not sure if its too soon to say this but. Alot of their early discussion was fluff, mostly rules jargon. Their first message actually really pertaining to reads and discussion was #148 where…

@guavagudetama

there are a couple reasons she could have said that but they all seem scummy with what you just said in mind

VOTE: MerpyDerpy

He than kinda glossed over this, switched his vote to Tutuu. but what susses me out the most is he than says

@guavagudetama

I didn’t like Merpy’s post about not knowing there was a vote today when she like. replied to people’s votes before that and talked about who we should vote/if we should vote noexe

which is like… okay on its own, but than the next time he was present in actual game discussion was #537 where he than hard defends merpy against Luka, and well I too was doing this, and I understand him and Luka had different knowledge and reasoning, its still VERY odd to go to bat for merpy that hard and switching votes on her accuser after accusing her very quickly earlier, not only that but after having her rated as his lowest town member. That gives me the ick.

bunching in Abi and Caitlin together because I have similar reads about them and are tired. I like them. Both of them have been unafraid to share their reads, explain their reads and most importantly been open to constant discussion about their own opinions, and willing to listen to others outputs on them well being completly forward about it too. I like and trust this type of behaviour.

This all being said I go to sleep now and I
VOTE: GuavaGudetama

Doleful’s post on me

[Psyx]

@guavagudetama

I can tell you that I think you/Caitlin/Abbi/Doleful is pure which leaves Luka/Merpy who are obv not w/w and Ritsu and tutuu

Did you ever respond to me asking how you townread me so early in the game, when most of my posts were NAI?

[MerpyDerpy]

I think TL;DR means summary. I can try for Arturo at least.
Arturo got voted by Dole, Tutuu, and Abigail.

1. Dole voted Arturo because they felt as though his posts were mostly fluff regarding rules and not as much focused on analysis of the game.
2. Tutuu voted Arturo because he “tried to kill their entire towncore”. That’s the only reason I’m seeing.
3. Abigail sheeped Dole from my understanding. They voted immediately after Dole gave their case, so that’s my assumption. I don’t have the details on the Tutuu push sadly.

[guavagudetama]

Not to you directly cuz I missed it but I explained it earlier

@Psyx

@guavagudetama

that was more of a “do you want to go to hell”

uhhh but I don’t think I’ll get misyeeted either cuz two people in this lobby know me pretty well
unless they’re scum

Oh lol

Honestly, this is my first time (lots of first times lel) playing this set-up and I’m kind of a mech potato. If I get sent to Hell, wouldn’t that lower town’s chances of yeeting wolves? Like, limited slots and stuff. But even disregarding that, the longer wolves hide, the easier it is for town to get discouraged/lose their temper/make biased reads (based on experience). So I don’t want to.

If you were going to get sent to Hell but could choose the time: would you rather it be earlier or later?

@Psyx

@tutuu

Who do you think the Mafia will kill night 1?

Depends on who the wolves are?

From my experience, wolves tend to hit those with the “opposite” thread position as them (ie vocal wolves would kill inactives/lowposters, while lurking wolves would kill town leaders). But more often than not, it’s the “generally townread” townies with accurate reads or have a reputation of being tough that get NK-ed on N1

These two posts feel very t!Psyx from the couple games I’ve played with you
t!Psyx has been very like
Serious and analytical
Almost all of your posts are actual content even if you don’t think they’re AI

@Psyx

@Psyx

ISO-ing Merpy, the way they’re wolfreading Luka/Abbi and townreading Tutuu/Cait has internal consistency with the way she explains how she makes reads: finding “willing to communicate”, “being transparent”, “showing a solving mindset/pushing people to solve” as townie signs (no matter how surface-level these signs are).

I find Luka vs Merpy funny tho, considering how good wolf!Luka is at appearing townie. I think Merpy is the type of player wolf!Luka would easily pocket.

Add: her Guava/Dole/Ritsu reads checks out too. It’s…interesting that she has exactly three wolfreads? And the lack of nullreads suggests that she doesn’t like them and gave a clear assignment to everyone

I like this post as well
Shows the thinky

Though in hindsight I don’t like how Merpy is SRing the two people that can read her best LOL
It’s fine I don’t need to worry about that unless tutuu or Ritsu flips town

[MerpyDerpy]

I can try and filter to find the reasons people are pushing Tutuu before EOD. Lemme check

[MerpyDerpy]

@guavagudetama

Though in hindsight I don’t like how Merpy is SRing the two people that can read her best LOL

The two people I scum-leaned were Abigail and Psyx. I’ve never played with either of these individuals…?

[guavagudetama]

@MerpyDerpy

The two people I scum-leaned were Abigail and Psyx. I’ve never played with either of these individuals…?

Were they not talking about you in that post wait

[MerpyDerpy]

You were town-lean for me, Arturo. I just trust Tutuu more.

@MerpyDerpy

Hell Phase 1 Read: Arturo (Guava)

Arturo: Town-Lean

Here’s the post in case you want to quickly review it.

[MerpyDerpy]

I have no idea what you’re talking about tbh.

[guavagudetama]

@Psyx

Add: her Guava/Dole/Ritsu reads checks out too. It’s…interesting that she has exactly three wolfreads?

About you I thought