Silent Hill Newbie Friendly JOAT 10er 4/10 Day 3 - Mafia Wins

[Drinks]

I’m confused what you mean by having yourself grouped with Eliza for a pair

[Demisha]

Zorvo brought up that they thought one of the more likely wolf pairs is me/Eliza

[Demisha]

If you go back a bit today you can find it, it was by the beginning of today.

[Drinks]

My current ranking of people in order is
Jaiden
You / Zorvo
Eliza

Haven’t really been looking at pairs of players all too much

[Zorvo]

I’m on Movile

[Zorvo]

Mobile*

[Zorvo]

I was gonna maybe talk with someone but I don’t think anyone is on right now.

[Demisha]

@ElizaThePsycho what are you gonna vote? are you gonna wait for EOD?

[ElizaThePsycho (Willow)]

I am going to vote drinks
probably

[ElizaThePsycho (Willow)]

Those are two separate answers btw
Although I am considering voting zorvo

[Zorvo]

@ElizaThePsycho

Those are two separate answers btw
Although I am considering voting zorvo

@ElizaThePsycho

Those are two separate answers btw
Although I am considering voting zorvo

If that happens I’d like to heavily consider @Drinks and @Jaiden be not ruling out Demi after I get night killed after the 1v1 with Eliza.

[Demisha]

If a town gets exe’d game’s over though, no night kill

[Zorvo]

@Demisha

If a town gets exe’d game’s over though, no night kill

That’s assuming Eliza is Town.
Meaning you would win unless the team is Drinks and Jaiden for some reason.

[Demisha]

No I was just saying, regardless of who gets exe’d

You’re not getting night killed 99.9% of the times here regardless though, you’re probably the least logical choice for night kill (assuming there’ll even be a night kill).

[Zorvo]

@Demisha

No I was just saying, regardless of who gets exe’d

You’re not getting night killed 99.9% of the times here regardless though, you’re probably the least logical choice for night kill (assuming there’ll even be a night kill).

If there is a 1v1 between me and a wolf and I somehow don’t die at night, mafia would basically be trying to make me play kingmaker and I don’t think that is an optimal play personally.

[Demisha]

@Drinks

Tell Kanave to stop sniping half the things I want to say

@Drinks

This feels like overcorrection, or maybe that it’s just hitting a lot of flags for me about not sticking to a point and jumping to different positions real quick.

@Drinks

I don’t mind holding off on the Demi spiral
Proposal to vote based on Steam games/playtime?

@Drinks

You’re solid town, practically confirmed. Congrats on the fastpass.

@Drinks

I dunno, that’s not always the fairest way to evaulate someone. Schedules and timezones and such.

@Drinks

I still don’t get Ranta
Is this an activity kill?

@Drinks

I don’t hate the vote onto Ranta, just a kinda dry area for me.
That’s below a good portion of others though, so if they don’t provide anything substantial in the next couple hours then I wouldn’t mind tossing a vote there as well.

@Drinks

Yeah I don’t shift my opinions too heavily unless someone starts going HARDCORE fish brained.

@Drinks

I can get behind the counter-push on Ranta’s attackers since I didn’t fully get it either. Outside of the v. Ranta specifically, Kanave read fairly good to me beforehand though. Do you think the push can be tunneling town or just raw evil?

@Drinks

My position is basically “The reason to axe Ranta is weak, but the people pushing them seem okay-at-best.” I’m curious about others’ reads into you, which seem to tick off flags a lot more than I’ve had onto you so far.

@Drinks

Agree on Plague, Ranta is a “wait and see” spot for me

@Drinks

Ranta’s probably going to be rotated out if that’s an option, considering low-involvement so far. I don’t want to kill into an almost blank slate.

@Drinks

If they kill a town, it’s their problem not ours

After ISOing Drinks I feel like they have flip flopped way too much on the Ranta decision when it was very easy as a town player to determine they should be voted basically from the end of day 1 onward, but Drinks continued to flip flop over and over up until now (where he’s barely now slightly being convinced on it).

To me this suggests the most likely wolf pair is Drinks/Zorvo

@Drinks

My current ranking of people in order is
Jaiden
You / Zorvo
Eliza

Haven’t really been looking at pairs of players all too much

Especially because even after all of that they find Jaiden more suspicious than Zorvo/Ranta somehow. This doesn’t line up because:

@Drinks

If Jaiden is a wolf, they’re approaching how they talk in game through a delicate townsfolk lens.
So for the time being I’m more reading that as genuine townsfolk brain talking.

@Drinks

My current map, with blanks as too dry to call:

Proven-Good
YouButWorse

Headed-Good
Eliza
Kanave
Drinks
Jaiden

Yellow Flagged
Demisha
PlagueSimp (Keep alive for them to kill Mafia though)

@Drinks

I can see this as town cannibalism or that you (evil) are pushing something aggressively that YBW (good) is saying isn’t a fair push. It’s particularly odd for me to chime in since I think Ranta isn’t really a suspect by low posts but that’s largely by benefit of doubt, so my reason for thinking your push on Ranta is bad is slightly different than YBW.
So basically tl;dr my view says this is YBW(Good) + Ranta (Good) v Kanave (Evil) or YBW (Good) + Ranta (???) v Kanave (Cannibal Good), YBW thinks it’s more likely the former of the two from the conversaion as I read it and while I trust her, it’s not enough of a credit to pile onto you.

@Drinks

I’ve had Jaiden high up.
I’d be upset to lose to Eliza wolf given the timeline of the game, not so much Jaiden.

The Jaiden suspicion is very much out of the blue, I feel like they’ve been making up all of the “lean hunchs” they’ve had up until now.

[Demisha]

With that said, like I mentioned, my prediction is that the wolf pair here is Drinks/Zorvo and I will make my vote before going to sleep (soon) because I don’t trust myself to wake up before EoD.

Still debating what the better vote between Drinks and Zorvo is for the time being.

[Demisha]

@Jaiden @ElizaThePsycho are you around by chance?

[Demisha]

Alright yeah, after a bit more of ISOing Zorvo and Eliza quickly and briefly on today’s votes im convinced, and with this im heading to bed.

/vote Drinks
@Host_Account_1 @ElizaThePsycho @Jaiden

[Zorvo]

/Vote Drinks

@Host_Account_1