reading wind I don’t think he’s done that either
he hasn’t been super sure, but like
he doesn’t feel lost/moping
also I don’t think he feels that towny? like if you take into account that he’s admitted he was doing towntells on purpose d1…
and his push on me doesn’t feel very… genuine.
like.
I’ve pointed out flaws in the analysis earlier, but as for why it’s scummy.
(also warning that despite my best efforts I am terrible at wording this into a coherent whole and am tempted to make diagrams instead of wallposts)
It feels like it’s just… assuming I’m scum and then supporting that. They cherrypicked things to support their argument (i.e. does my push on Psyx just… mean nothing), and the points they picked are given a very cut-and-dry interpretation that ignores all the nuance of the game. They don’t seem to be trying to see any town perspective in my actions.
They start with “oh I must be trying to kill a claimed PR” which is a pretty questionable point. Sure it doesn’t make much sense for town, but it makes less sense for wolves. Then they talk about my push on Abbi, but reading carefully they actually only use it to do 2 things. The first is that it makes my push on lol more realistic from a wolf pov (and ignore that it also makes it make more sense from town). The second is that it looks like I’m trying to look good by being off-wagon. Which is not only demonstrably false but super surface level. They don’t check whether my reasons for not voting Guava look fake, or whether my reasons for voting Abbi looked genuine.
The other point he makes is lol getting vanillaized implicates me. Which while true is a very cut-and-dry point that inevitably is filled with WIFOM. The point does also implicate him, though. Also, he notably doesn’t mention the Cait kill, which implicates me but not him. I can’t help but think he is a wolf who is making this connection because that was his reason for vanillaizing lol.