Consider posting less
1 Like
bionic/tutuu/bystander/windward
1 Like
No
ooo cool list of names
1 Like
at least 4/4 maybe 5/4
1 Like
Phraze has three posts, but I actually found her more wolfy than null.
It felt like she was trying to pull some sense of presence and commentary on the game without actually doing anything. She noted how many posts there were, she noted how she’d played with somebody before, and then she seemingly ran out of things to say. It creates a nervous impression.
nah it’s 2(1.3+✓9/3)/4
Oh, I somehow missed the fact that her last post was a response to your asking. I would, in fact, then find that a little bit towny, as she could have leveraged that to try to look townier in a dozen ways that she didn’t really take. I agree that I am not sure if I believe it, though.
To be fair, even townies can be nervous at game start
I’d say let Phraze cook a bit before making any real judgement
VOTE: Phraze
This is a towny vote.
I will say I talked a bit with May and he mentioned Phraze slanked in the last game he saw her in
so maybe Phraze frequently [slanks / low efforts], and we shouldn’t read a lack of effort towards looking better as towny
When was this game played?
idk
I would ask May but that’s probably an integrity breach
I can try to find Phraze’s games on MU for more data tho
1 Like
I hallucinated this. She didnt say that shes excited in the fol discord server or in the sign up thread like i thought
So nvm
(I suspected her claiming excitement and then feeling afraid of wolfing but she didnt claim it she just said she wants to play)
Lmao
1 Like
So it really is probably just a “let Phraze cook a bit before making any sort of judgement” lmao
This may be a fairly objective piece of meta, but I would still prefer not to rely on details from games I was not in to judge somebody’s character. It would be one thing if I had full information here, but I do not know the nature of that “slanking” (it is a broad term: I frequently struggle to meet post minimums and can be difficult to get a hold of, but I do not think I am a player one would consider “low effort”), I do not know what causes her to low-post (a player who has a busy schedule may give little time but great effort toward their posts, a player who does not care much about mafia may give great time but little effort in their posts, and this affects the nature of reading them), and I do not know when it occurred (much can change in a few years, and a player returning to mafia is less likely to put a low level of effort into a game). I would prefer to just take this game as evidence in isolation.
2 Likes
So many words to say “second hand meta can get fucked”
1 Like
I do not think passing judgment prevents Phraze from “cooking”, so to speak. It is fine to make interim reads on players who you believe will provide more readable content later on. It often enhances the readability of their later content, as it provides them with a specific pressure to respond to. I think it is fine to pass judgment on Phraze right now, so long as we understand there is not much information to go off of here and remain open-minded. This kind of attitude often incentivizes players to avoid posting to prevent players from expressing solid reads on them.
2 Likes