Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 1 - Days 1 & 2

[katze]

i wish i was a little bit taller

[nightingale]

because i played with you in fam2 and have respect for your wolfgame
you dont have a large tonal gap
you can still solve well as w
but im not superfamiliar with your meta
i dont know any tells i can actually reliably use on you other than analyzing how youve treated flipped slots on a game-wide level

thats why i consistently put you off until later game to read

[SaulGoodman]

i hardclaim that you won’t need to read me past today

anyway
fair enough… i guess
this is why i prefer people thinking i suck at the game

[nightingale]

thats not to say i wont try to read you today
i just think its unlikely to produce anything ill be confident in

[spf]

uwu

[nightingale]

1-shot compulsive dier

[spf]

i think @katze asked me to expand on my concerns on min, but to be clear, i do not have any concerns about min that i can remember. i do not have any thoughts about their posts at all

[SaulGoodman]

what do people think about sufdaddy
i think he’s been townread for nebulous reasons and his macro is soft defending people i think are probably mafia and shading people i think are probably town
but like… his reasons aren’t terrible, so on a micro level he’s fine i guess
flips will help but eh

[BradLand]

@SPF

Have you spoken where your head is at with the game as a whole yet and can you point that out or can you type that up now?

[SaulGoodman]

@nightingale

results unclear
i mean
he references a rue push for the first time like, 30 minutes after it was last mentioned? which i generally write of as kinda good but still definitely a shrug
on the other hand i dont like how he continually offers to explain his reads then never is able to come up with anything remotely deep
like
i dont care if he never explains his reads
its just that he does it really shallowly that it doesnt feel like he has super deep thoughts
like normally if someone with deep thoughts were to go part of the way in they go all the way in
in a long ramply post like im doing right now
you dont just dip and give something like “hmmmmmm i feel vaguely weird about this and i dont think that kat thinks that this post is real, and then i dont vibe with the conclusions” and leave it at that

@nightingale

VOTE: Heisenberg
yeah
i dont really like the inability to explain it past “uncanny valley”
its like
capturing the memory of a vivid color (feeling of analysis)
without actually constructing the object that produced that color that would have to be there, even if its not the most striking part about it (the thoughts that lead to that specific feeling)

this is like the best way of describing geyde’s posts i love it night is town (please accept my pocket)

[spf]

i think that sabi and night are town

i have a townlean on guilo and hally

i have light townpings from phraze rue you and eliza (non-maf, could be 3p) that haven’t fully crystalized into a townread yet

beyond that my thoughts are a bit scattered

[spf]

no empty head thoughts

[BradLand]

Okay, that’s fine enough, thanks.

[sufdaddy]

which people and defenses/shadings are you referring to? other than zorvo, I already saw your posts on that

[Achromatic]

memes is like, super towny lol

[SaulGoodman]

min and guillo are two people i think are probably town
first one is more excusable because you don’t really know them but guillo feels pretty likely to be a villager to me

[Achromatic]

I thought he got way too defensive with me but also I have no idea if they are just touchy and I haven’t looked at him in a macro view.

[Achromatic]

call it a hunch

[Memes]

They got defensive with me when i questioned their neutral read on Zorvo too. He believes Zorvo is jester and not scum this we should not chop him.

What people are failing to realize or maybe they dont have this meta but the “TWTBAW” theory does not apply to Zorvo.

[Heisenberg]

Reading up